EpicureanFriends.com: The Online Epicurean Philosophy User Group

Announcements

  • Cassius

    If anyone here speaks Spanish, please be sure to see Titus' post here: Buenos libros sobre la filosofia epicurea en espanol

  • Cassius

  • Cassius

    Please see Michele Pinto's post here for a link to a live Google talk presentation from Rome (in English) this Saturday the 24th. One of the presentations is Voula Tsouna on "Revisiting the Method of Multiple Explanations" and that looks particularly interesting: News from Italy - you'll love it!

  • Cassius

    Happy Twentieth, everyone!

  • Cassius

    The Text for Episode 41 of the Lucretius Podcast is now posted. This section from Book 3 focuses on the mind and "spirit," and harks back to the difference between "properties" and "events." We tend to refer to this concept as that of "emergent properties," but there is no consensus on the best terminolog. If you have a chance to glance at this text and have any questions or comments you would like us to discuss, please post! Episode Forty-One [Pre-Production] The Nature of the Mind and Spirit Is Complex; Sense is Not a Property of The Elements That Make Them, But An Event of Their Combination And Motions

  • Cassius

    Episode 40 of the Lucretius Today podcast is now available: Episode Forty - The Mind and Spirit Are Bodily, Composed of Very Fine Atoms

  • Cassius

    Episode 39 of the Lucretius Today podcast is now available: Episode Thirty-Nine: The Mind And Spirit Are Not Supernatural But Parts of A Man Just Like The Head and Foot This week contains some challenging material on unfamiliar concepts such as "harmony," so we particularly invite your comments and suggestions so we can clarify the material as we proceed.

  • Cassius

    Reminder: To select between dark and light site themes, scroll to the very bottom of any page and select "Change Style." You'll then see a list of options from which to choose.

  • Cassius

    Our front page here contains an "Active Threads" list. One goal I have is to see less of my smiling face in that list of thread-starters, and more icons of other people! :-) One of the best things you can do to help the forum is to start threads on any topics of relevance to the board that come to your mind. When you have a chance take a glance at the list of forums and post on a detailed topic, or just start with whatever you like and post it in General Discussion Forum - Welcome! - we can move it to a subforum later. Thanks!

  • Cassius

    Episode 38 of the Lucretius Today podcast is now available: Episode Thirty-Eight: Start of Book Three - Epicurus Our Guide Who Dispels The Darkness of Error and Fear of Hell I think you will find this is one of our better episodes, and as it more general than many, it is a great place to start listening if you've missed prior episodes or are just new to the podcast.

  • Cassius

  • Cassius

    It's been reported that the board may say that it is sending new users an email with a registration code, but that the email is not sent. If anyone has any registration issues please email Cassius@epicureanfriends.com and we will get it straightened out - but as far as I understand the system, no registration code is necessary.

  • Cassius

    Due to recent interest we are reworking the group of forums devoted to historical Epicureans, as per Request For Suggestions For Entries in This "Epicurean Figures of the Past" Forum . Please check out the existing list of subforums, and if you have suggestions for figures who should have their own sections (especially figures who ived prior to the end of the Ancient World) please let us know.

  • Cassius

    Episode 36 of the Lucretius Today Podcast is now available: Episode Thirty-Six - No Single Thing of A Kind: Earth Not The Only Home of Life

  • Cassius

    Episode 35 of the Lucretius Today Podcast is now available: Episode Thirty-Five - More Reasons Why The Atoms Cannot Possess The Faculty of Sense

  • Cassius

    Episode 34 of the Lucretius Today Podcast is now available: Episode Thirty-Four - The Atoms Do Not Possess A Faculty of Sensation

  • Cassius

    Episode 33 of the Lucretius Today Podcast is Now Available: Episode Thirty-Three - More on The Implications of the Colorless Atoms

  • Cassius

    Episode 32 of the Lucretius Today Podcast Is Now Available: Episode Thirty-Two: The Atoms Are Colorless, But the Implications Are Not

  • Cassius

    Episode Two of Joshua's EpicureaPoetica is now live! Check it out here: EpicureaPoetica---Episode 2

  • Cassius

    Happy Twentieth of August!

Welcome to our Online Community of Epicureans, where we study Epicurus, apply Epicurean philosophy to our own lives, and"strike a blow for Epicurus, that great man whose holiness and divinity of nature were not shams, who alone had and imparted true insight into the good, and who brought deliverance to all that consorted with him." All are welcome to read and ask questions, but only firm friends of Epicurean Philosophy in accord with our Not Neo-Epicurean, But Epicurean statement and our Posting Policy statement are granted full posting privileges, so here you will find a truly supportive community of Epicurean Friends.

Popular Links: New Content | Active Threads | Forum List | Unread Posts | General Discussion | Upcoming Events |Last 100 Threads | Unanswered Posts | Dashboard | Image Gallery | Filebase | Articles | FAQ |Core Texts | Wiki | Community Standards | Major Projects | The Lucretius Today Podcast

New Users: Please scroll to the bottom of the page for introductory material.

To select dark or light site theme, select "Change Style" at bottom of page.

Recent Activities

  • Elayne

    Post
    Don, one thing I always remember is that it was against the law upon pain of death to refuse to participate in worship and rituals. No doubt in those rituals, things were said which completely went against Epicurus' description of the gods, because the…
  • Don

    Post
    (Quote from Susan Hill)

    I wouldn't say that you're alone. Epicurus obviously saw the gods as important as evidenced by the Principal Doctrines, the letter to Menoikeus, etc. I think it behooves us to understand why. He took part in the community…
  • Cassius

    Post
    (Quote from Elayne)

    Here I agree and would say that we still need to be more accurate as to our standard for what is a "god." Did Epicurus himself qualify? If so, how? I don't think we are sure whether that assertion was intended to be figurative or…
  • Elayne

    Post
    One of the difficulties in quoting the texts is that cases can be made for conclusions out of alignment with the philosophy as a whole, if one is not cautious. Although I like DeWitt, I don't consider him necessarily accurate on every single issue, and
  • Cassius

    Post
    OK I have a few minutes to come back to this.

    (Quote from Susan Hill)


    I do not read anyone as saying that we should, or the texts say to, reject any data from any of the three legs of Epicurus' canon. I see everything as a question of verifiability…

Active Threads

    1. Topic
    2. Replies
    3. Last Reply
    1. Reverence and Awe In Epicurean Philosophy 67

      • Don
    2. Replies
      67
      Views
      338
      67
    3. Elayne

    1. Buenos libros sobre la filosofia epicurea en espanol 2

      • Titus
    2. Replies
      2
      Views
      11
      2
    3. Titus

    1. News from Italy - you'll love it! 18

      • michelepinto
    2. Replies
      18
      Views
      229
      18
    3. michelepinto

    1. Episode Forty-One - The Nature of the Mind and Spirit Is Complex; Sense is Not a Property of The Elements That Make Them, But An Event of Their Combination And Motions 2

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      2
      Views
      154
      2
    3. Cassius

    1. Episode Forty-Two [Pre-Production] - The Mind works through the senses; it is a relatively small part of the body; the Mind has more power than the "spirit," but both mind and spirit are mortal

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      0
      Views
      22
    1. David Konstan - Life worthy of the Gods 3

      • timrobbe
    2. Replies
      3
      Views
      55
      3
    3. timrobbe

    1. Notes on "Epicurus and His Gods" by A.J. Festugiere 4

      • Godfrey
    2. Replies
      4
      Views
      67
      4
    3. Susan Hill

    1. Problems in Frances Wright's "A Few Days in Athens" 6

      • Elayne
    2. Replies
      6
      Views
      128
      6
    3. Cassius

    1. Twentieth Skype Call (10-20-2020) 21

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      21
      Views
      190
      21
    3. Cassius

    1. Exchange With A Stoic (Donald Robertson) on "Engagement" and Pleasure vs. Virtue 4

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      4
      Views
      593
      4
    3. Cassius

    1. Warnings For New Readers of A Few Days In Athens

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      0
      Views
      38
    1. Epicurean Outlooks on Skepticism 6

      • A_Gardner
    2. Replies
      6
      Views
      122
      6
    3. Cassius

    1. Wax Ring Carving—Second Attempt 21

      • JJElbert
    2. Replies
      21
      Views
      1.2k
      21
    3. Cassius

    1. Phaedo and prolepses 8

      • Godfrey
    2. Replies
      8
      Views
      155
      8
    3. Cassius

    1. Episode Forty - The Mind and Spirit Are Bodily, Composed of Very Fine Atoms 7

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      7
      Views
      173
      7
    3. Cassius

    1. Episode Thirty-Nine: The Mind And Spirit Are Not Supernatural But Parts of A Man Just Like The Head and Foot 11

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      11
      Views
      295
      11
    3. Don

    1. Epicurean Idioms To Be Deciphered - "Against him who places himself with head where his feet should be." 2

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      2
      Views
      100
      2
    3. Cassius

    1. The Lamps are Going Out All Over the Imperium 1

      • JJElbert
    2. Replies
      1
      Views
      68
      1
    3. Cassius

    1. Welcome GeorgeS! 5

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      5
      Views
      192
      5
    3. JJElbert

    1. Annotated Menoikeus Project: First Draft 5

      • Don
    2. Replies
      5
      Views
      238
      5
    3. Cassius

    1. The Dangers of Misdirected Increase of Knowledge 28

      • Susan Hill
    2. Replies
      28
      Views
      385
      28
    3. Cassius

    1. Welcome OpulentOkapi!

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      0
      Views
      78
    1. Elayne Reviews Alan Reye's Editorial on Thomas Jefferson 1

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      1
      Views
      73
      1
    3. Cassius

    1. Welcome Konstantin! 1

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      1
      Views
      55
      1
    3. Charles

    1. Can Emotions be Trusted? 42

      • Susan Hill
    2. Replies
      42
      Views
      429
      42
    3. JJElbert

Most Discussed Threads

    1. Topic
    2. Replies
    3. Last Reply
    1. Discussion of the Society of Epicurus' 20 Tenets of 12/21/19 173

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      173
      Views
      15k
      173
    3. Mike Anyayahan

    1. Glossary - What is the Epicurean Definition of "Pleasure?" 125

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      125
      Views
      11k
      125
    3. Hiram

    1. The Neglect of Metrodorus’ Economics 81

      • Hiram
    2. Replies
      81
      Views
      7.7k
      81
    3. elli

    1. The Notre Dame Fire 78

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      78
      Views
      10k
      78
    3. JJElbert

    1. Epicureans and the Ancient Greek Gods (Imagery of "Gods" / "Gods Among Men") 70

      • Matt
    2. Replies
      70
      Views
      11k
      70
    3. Cassius

    1. Reverence and Awe In Epicurean Philosophy 67

      • Don
    2. Replies
      67
      Views
      338
      67
    3. Elayne

    1. References to Epicurus' Attitude Toward The "Place of the Sciences And Liberal Arts" 63

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      63
      Views
      3.3k
      63
    3. Cassius

    1. Nate's "Allegory of the Oasis" Graphic 63

      • Cassius
    2. Replies
      63
      Views
      12k
      63
    3. Cassius

    1. Dead Reddit / The "Isms" Thread 62

      • Nate
    2. Replies
      62
      Views
      7.7k
      62
    3. Elayne

    1. Epicurus, gods and God 57

      • Godfrey
    2. Replies
      57
      Views
      7k
      57
    3. Cassius

Featured Images

  • Not Neo-Epicurean, But Epicurean

    Not Neo-Epicurean, But Epicurean

    278
    0
    1
  • After 2000 Years Still The Three Main Contenders For Your Mind

    After 2000 Years Still The Three Main Contenders For Your Mind

    400
    2
    1
  • Autun mosaic from The House of the Greek Authors, Musée Rolin

    Autun mosaic from The House of the Greek Authors, Musée Rolin

    316
    0
    0
  • On Living Unknown While Locating Your School In A High Traffic Area

    On Living Unknown While Locating Your School In A High Traffic Area

    378
    0
    1
  • Epicurus Greece Stamp 2019

    Epicurus Greece Stamp 2019

    481
    0
    2
  • Death Is Nothing To Us

    Death Is Nothing To Us

    • Nate
    297
    0
    1
  • Plato's Metaphysical Contradiction

    Plato's Metaphysical Contradiction

    • Nate
    306
    0
    1
  • Epicurus Skipping Mysticism

    Epicurus Skipping Mysticism

    • Nate
    301
    0
    0
  • Plato's Distracted Boyfriend

    Plato's Distracted Boyfriend

    • Nate
    377
    1
    2
  • Concepts As Black As Hell

    Concepts As Black As Hell

    329
    0
    0
  • PD9 - Just As All Colors Are Colorful

    PD9 - Just As All Colors Are Colorful

    334
    0
    1
  • Agostino Scilla

    Agostino Scilla

    429
    0
    0

Featured Articles

    Haris Dimitriadis is author of “The Pleasant Life – The Philosophy of Epicurus.” Born in Greece, Haris studied Mathematics at the Aristotelian University of Thessaloniki as well as Economics at the London School of Economics. His career spanned the business and banking industries and has settled into retirement. Through climbing the corporate ladder he found it brought little peace of mind and turned his attention to the philosophy of Epicurus. Haris can be contacted through his

    Read More

    As much as Epicurus advised against devoting life to politics, it appears that the politicians cannot return the favor and leave Epicurus alone. On both left and right, partisans of every cause except that of Epicurus himself feel compelled to enlist Epicurus as a saint or a demon, for or against their own preferred political position. The result can leave us feeling like Tennyson's Charge of the Light Brigade, facing volleys not of cannons but of false accusations against Epicurus

    Read More


    From Diogenes Laertius, Book 10 (The Biography of Epicurus), we read something that may lead us again to revisit the matter of the apparent chronic ill health of Epicurus, and how the great philosopher confronted and dealt with serious bodily health issues.


    Here is the excerpt by Diogenes Laertius: “Timocrates, the brother of Metrodorus, in his treatise entitled the Merry Guests, and this Timocrates had been a disciple in his school, though he afterwards abandoned it; and he says that he

    Read More

    Inspired by the considerations on the Epicurean friendship of Phillp Mithis in the book "The Ethical Theory of Epicurus - The pleasures of Invulnerability," I want to summarize the thought of Epicurus on friendship, trying to use his own words as much as possible, and adding mine where necessary. I am indebted to Carlo Diano because his thematic collection of Epicurus's maxims was essential. The first Epicurean festival, whose general theme was about friendship, was also very useful.

    Read More

    The following is a short summary of principles which are important for understanding Epicurus and participating in discussion at the Epicurean Philosophy Facebook Group. It is not intended to address all aspects of Epicurean philosophy. As time allows we will supplement the citations below with more citations and explanatory articles.


    1. Not “flourishing,” “human potential,” “self-actualization,” or “meaningfulness,” but happiness grounded in the feeling of pleasure.


    2. Not

    Read More

    Not "absence of pain" as a full statement of the goal of life, but “the Feelings are two, pleasure and pain” and “Pleasure is the beginning and the end of a happy life.”


    Brief: The feelings are only two, pleasure and pain—there is no third state such as neutral, and there are no “fancy pleasures” which are different from regular pleasures. Because there is no neutral, reducing pain in life is only possible if there is a corresponding increase in pleasure. The extent

    Read More

    PREFACE 1.

    We often confuse the issue of the possibility of free will exercising with the issue of its existence. When we are unable to exercise it we say with sloppiness that it does not exist. This "I want but I can’t or I don’t want but I am forced" puts into testing our individual self-esteem. But any coercion and enforcement exists precisely because there is free will and some of the people have the power to exercise it, usually at the expense of the others.


    We have extreme

    Read More

Featured Documents

New User Orientation



This is the place to study and discuss Epicurus with people who - can you believe it? - aren't just Stoics in disguise, but who actually support and promote Epicurean philosophy. On your first visit, check out this full home page, including the Not Neo-Epicurean, But Epicurean and our Posting Policy statements. Look around the Forums arranged by Topic. A good place to sample the latest conversations is by clicking Latest Threads, or simply start with our General Forum. After that, bookmark the Dashboard, so that when you come back you'll see all the latest postings and announcements. Other key links are the FAQ where we have answers to often-asked questions, and our Wiki, which features one of the best collections of Lucretius and other Epicurean texts that you'll find anywhere. Don't miss the forum devoted to reviews of modern books, articles, and video-multimedia devoted to Epicurus. Do you prefer a page theme that is lighter, darker, or a different color? Go to the bottom right and click "Change Style!" Thanks for dropping by and enjoy your stay - here our highest goal is Pleasure!


Also, we are continuing our on-line group discussions of Norman DeWitt's Epicurus and His Philosophy. Please check the announcements at the top of this page for confirmation of the time and date of the next session. Discussion outlines are posted here.


Please note our other ongoing projects: For our latest translations and research into the Doctrines, Sayings, and Letters of Epicurus, check our wiki.


There is also a great need for an authoritative online free edition of Lucretius' On The Nature of Things. At our Wiki page, we have two public domain versions (Munro and Bailey) and we are currently working on adding the 1743 Daniel Browne edition, which has the Latin text on the facing page of the original. In order to allow the reader to crosscheck the English translation, we are cross-referencing each translation the equivalent passage in the Latin text. If you have time to help in either of these projects, please let us know by posting in the appropriate forum thread. Our latest project is www.EpicureanRadio.com, a streaming service that we hope to expand into a full "Epicurean Radio Station." Check it out in the new subforum devoted to it!


If you have come across Epicurean philosophy in the past but been confused by commentators who assert - incorrectly - that Epicurus advocated an ascetic or passive lifestyle, you'll want to check out our table of Major Issues In Understanding Epicurean Philosophy. We're glad to help with your study of Epicurus - just ask in the forums! In the meantime, here is the advice of Thomas Jefferson on living an active Epicurean life:


"I take the liberty of observing that you are not a true disciple of our master Epicurus in indulging the indolence to which you say you are yielding. One of his canons, you know, was that “that indulgence which prevents a greater pleasure, or produces a greater pain, is to be avoided.” Your love of repose will lead, in its progress, to a suspension of healthy exercise, a relaxation of mind, an indifference to everything around you, and finally to a debility of body, and hebetude of mind, the farthest of all things from the happiness which the well-regulated indulgences of Epicurus ensure; fortitude, you know is one of his four cardinal virtues. That teaches us to meet and surmount difficulties; not to fly from them, like cowards; and to fly, too, in vain, for they will meet and arrest us at every turn of our road. Weigh this matter well; brace yourself up." - Thomas Jefferson to William Short, October 31, 1819.


A Feature of Our Forum - Follow The Advice Of Epicurus: Outline Your Understanding Of Philosophy


Epicurus' Letter to Herodotus: "Those who have made some advance in the survey of the entire system ought to fix in their minds under the principal headings an elementary outline of the whole treatment of the subject. For a comprehensive view is often required, the details but seldom. ... For it is impossible to gather up the results of continuous diligent study of the entirety of things unless we can embrace in short formulas and hold in mind all that might have been accurately expressed even to the minutest detail."


Thomas Jefferson wrote in a private letter "I too am an Epicurean" and drafted his own outline of Epicurean philosophy.  If you'd like to see what Jefferson wrote, and  get help in drafting your own, click here.


We hope you will consider signing up for an account so you can participate fully here at the forum. For a brief introduction to the orientation of this website, please review our Community Standards / Terms of Use , and check out our brief video Major Characteristics of Epicurean Philosophy.



A Note On Why This Website Is Not "Stoic In Disguise" -  

Many people who come here have been influenced by the alleged importance of a distinction between "kinetic" and "katastematic" pleasure. This argument is unsound, probably not of Epicurean origin at all, and can be very damaging to a proper understanding of Epicurus. To research this issue, start with Boris Nikolsky's "Epicurus on Pleasure," which argues that the katastematic issue was not introduced by Epicurus and reflects a later Stoic-influenced viewpoint. Next, read the chapters on Epicurus in Gosling and Taylor's "The Greeks on Pleasure," from which Nikolsky got the inspiration for his article. The whole section on Epicurus is good, but be sure to read their Chapter 19 "Katastematic and Kinetic Pleasure." Add to that the Wentham article "Cicero's Interpretation of Katastematic Pleasure," which highlights how emphasis on katastematic pleasure contradicts other core aspects of Epicurean philosophy.


Those shorter articles should then take you back to the best general book on Epicurus, Norman DeWitt's "Epicurus and His Philosophy."  DeWitt provides a sweeping overview of Epicurus which hardly mentions the katastematic - kinetic distinction except to point out how - even if one considers the categories relevant - Epicurean philosophy embraces both types. If you don't read anything else at this website, check out the articles listed above, and you'll see how important this issue is to a proper understanding of Epicurean philosophy. And if you are brand new to the study of Epicurus, be sure to start your study with DeWitt's "Epicurus and His Philsosophy."

Foundations of Epicurean Philosophy