1. Home
    1. Study Guide
    2. Community Standards
    3. Site Map
    4. Quizzes
    5. Articles On Physics
    6. Articles On Canonics
    7. Articles On Ethics
    8. All Articles
    9. Elli's Blog Posts
    10. Kalosyni's Blog
    11. All Blog Posts
  2. Lexicon
    1. Lexicon Home
    2. FAQ
    3. Files
    4. Search Assistance
    5. Foundations
    6. Navigation Outlines
    7. Reading List
    8. Key Pages
    9. Last Changes
  3. Forum
    1. Full Forum List
    2. Welcome Threads
    3. Ancient Texts Forum
    4. Physics
    5. Canonics
    6. Ethics
    7. Forum Shortcuts
    8. Forum Navigation Map
    9. Featured
    10. Most Discussed
  4. Latest
    1. New Activity
    2. Latest Threads
    3. Dashboard
    4. Search By Tag
    5. Complete Tag List
  5. Podcast
    1. Lucretius Today Podcast
    2. Episode Guide
    3. Lucretius Today At Youtube
    4. EpicureanFriends Youtube Page
  6. Texts
    1. Overview
    2. Torquatus On Ethics
    3. Velleius On Divinity
    4. Diogenes Laertius
    5. Principal Doctrines
    6. Vatican Collection
    7. Lucretius
    8. Herodotus
    9. Pythocles
    10. Menoeceus
    11. Fragments - Usener Collection
    12. Greek/Latin Help
  7. Gallery
    1. Latest Images
    2. Featured images
    3. Latest Comments
  8. More
    1. Featured Content
    2. Logbook
    3. EF ToDo List
  • Login
  • Register
  • Search
This Thread
  • Everywhere
  • This Thread
  • This Forum
  • Forum
  • Articles
  • Blog Articles
  • Files
  • Gallery
  • Pages
  • Wiki
  • FAQ
  • More Options
  1. EpicureanFriends - Classical Epicurean Philosophy
  2. Forum
  3. Ethics - How To Live
  4. Pleasure Is The Guide of Life

Under What Circumstances, If Any, Would An Epicurean Choose A Course That Produced (For Example) 98% Pleasure And 2% Pain Over A Course That Was 100% Pleasure and 0% Pain?

  • Cassius
  • November 9, 2026 at 12:00 PM
  • Go to last post
  • Cassius
    5 - Administrator
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    115,983
    Posts
    15,981
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • November 9, 2026 at 12:00 PM
    • #1

    Separating out "pleasure in the abstract" into practical decisionmaking involving "specific pleasures" probably requires us to face a number of questions, including these:

    1. Is it true that some pleasures are "more pleasurable" than others?
    2. If this is NOT true, then
      1. is it appropriate to stop and say the answer to the question is "Never," because pleasures are totally interchangeable and even the "simplest pleasures" are just as pleasurable as "complex pleasures"?
    3. If this IS true, then
      1. Does that mean that some situations which involve 2% pain are more preferable that some situations which involve 0% pain?
      2. What situations would those be? How would we describe the factors that would have to be weighed?

    My own view is that there are clearly situations where the intensity or duration or parts of the body affected would justify choosing a course of action that produced 98% pleasure and 2% pain would be preferable to a situation that involved pleasures that were "lesser" but still involved 100% of total experience.

    But I also have the impression that many people who study Epicurus will say that "100% pleasure is always better."

    How would we untangle these questions? This is just another way of asking a question that I don't think modern discussion of Epicurus addresses very clearly, but which I think must be addressed for the philosophy to make sense. I feel sure the ancient Epicureans would have had a quick answer to this.

  • Cassius November 9, 2026 at 12:01 PM

    Changed the title of the thread from “Under What Circumstances, If Any, Would An Epicurean Choose A Course That Produced (For Example) 98% Pleasure And 2% Pain Over A Course That Was 100% Pleasure?” to “Under What Circumstances, If Any, Would An Epicurean Choose A Course That Produced (For Example) 98% Pleasure And 2% Pain Over A Course That Was 100% Pleasure and 0% Pain?”.
  • Cassius
    5 - Administrator
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    115,983
    Posts
    15,981
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • November 9, 2026 at 1:42 PM
    • #2

    I would think that the following from Diogenes Laertius is relevant to this question of how Epicurus looks at conceptual terminology and how concepts can vary in degree but still be essentially the same.

    Quote

    [121] He will erect statues of others, but whether he had one himself or not, he would be indifferent. Only the Wise man could discourse rightly on music and poetry, but in practice he would not compose poems. One wise man is not wiser than another.

    [122] They hold that faults are not all of equal gravity, that health is a blessing to some, but indifferent to others, that courage does not come by nature, but by a calculation of advantage.


    So even though most of us would readily say that some actions are "more wise" than are others, Epicurus can still say that "to be wise" means that one wise man is not wiser than another.

    Similarly most of us would probably agree that faults have a common unity in being faults, and yet clearly some faults are of more gravity - can cause more pain - than others.

    Even the word "health," a term which we can see as easy to apply and of equal value for everyone, and for which there is a great disposition to erect as a goal of life, is a blessing to some but a matter of indifference to thers.

    We should probably ask the same question about happiness. Can one happy man be more happy than another? Is happiness like wisdom, for which one wise many is not wiser than another, or is happiness like health, in which one healhy man can be healthier (or at least value it more) than another.

    And of course I'd ask the same question about "ataraxia"? Can one many who is not disturbed be less disturbed than another?

    I am writing all this to bring out what I think is an underappreciated point: That talking about happiness and pleasure in the abstract is clearly the best philosophical goal, but the analysis doesn't stop there. There are varying kinds (and degrees?) of happiness and varying kinds and degrees of pleasure . (Also at 122: "They say also that there are two ideas of happiness, complete happiness, such as belongs to a god, which admits of no increase, and the happiness which is concerned with the addition and subtraction of pleasures.")

    What do we tell people about how to determine which pleasure is "greater" when we explain what Epicurus meant when he talked about the wise man at the banquet or the question of how to consider length of time in measuring pleasure?

  • Cassius
    5 - Administrator
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    115,983
    Posts
    15,981
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • November 9, 2026 at 1:52 PM
    • #3

    I want to throw this into the mix as well:

    It seems clear that the question of identifying a "heap" (the sorites issue) was known to Epicurus, and his statement that he would not know the good if you subtracted the various specific pleasures that he listed (in the saying recorded by Cicero) is a restatement of how "the good" does not exist apart from specific things which we find to be good, just as the heap does not exist apart from the grains that compose it.

    In discussing heaps of sand, we can easily understand that one heap may contain more grains than another heap, and therefore be larger and recognizably be different. But is not the point that both heaps, no matter how much larger one may be than the other, are both "heaps?" In other words a heap does not become more of a heap, strictly speaking, by adding more grains of sand.

    Happiness considered to be a life of pleasure is conceptually the same. Whether the life is 100% pleasure or 98% pleasure, or whether it lasts ten years or a hundred years, it remains a life of pleasure and therefore a happy life, and it can be legitimately said one life of happiness is not more of a life of happiness than another, even though the larger one would clearly be preferable if you have the choice between them.

    I am not saying that this is the only way to explain why PD 19 says what it says (PD19. Infinite time contains no greater pleasure than limited time, if one measures, by reason, the limits of pleasure). However this is one plausible explanation, and any competing explanations have to be equally or more consistent with common sense reasoning and Epicurus' other sayings.

  • Noah Calderon
    2 - Guest Level 2
    Points
    94
    Posts
    7
    Quizzes
    2
    Quiz rate
    75.0 %
    • November 17, 2026 at 6:06 AM
    • #4

    This is a very difficult topic to wrap my head around. People are temperamentally different, which is to say that they are more sensitive to different kinds of pleasure and pain and a lot of that could be viewed as a completely standard interface with Nature, who provides us with pleasure and pain as signals for how to live our life. So when we talk about these things we can easily confuse concepts. So for instance does the unavoidable existence of a natural but unnecessary desire ruin the 100% pleasure involved in the safer route and therefore actually make it more painful than the more proactive 98% pleasure mixed with 2% pain route.

    This is unfortunately very tricky to get a single clear answer on since we are not the hypothesized gods whose absolute diligence guarantees them 100% pleasure all of the time. We can only try to persuade our Nature. However if I were to settle on a philosophical framework that made communicating about these the easiest possible I would probably interpret PD3 in the literal sense that pleasure is complete when all pain is removed.

    This question is very interesting, and I think the answer is in how we would define pleasure and pain, since that resolves the confusion in why we would ever "choose" pain. I am open to correction, though, since I am still studying.

  • Cassius
    5 - Administrator
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    115,983
    Posts
    15,981
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • November 17, 2026 at 8:41 AM
    • #5

    I think you make a lot of sense Noah. Just a couple of comments on what you wrote:

    Quote from Noah Calderon

    So for instance does the unavoidable existence of a natural but unnecessary desire ruin the 100% pleasure involved in the safer route and therefore actually make it more painful than the more proactive 98% pleasure mixed with 2% pain route.

    I think you're right because you're talking about the issue involved in looking at pleasure as a general concept vs looking at it as a specific set of experiences in a specific life. It's always appropriate to view 100% pleasure as more "pure" or "complete" from a conceptual point of view, but that's not the same as looking at a real life and saying that I would happily take 2% pain in order to live 98% of my life experiencing things that i find deeply rich and intense rather than just mildly pleasurable. Pleasures are always pleasurable, but that doesn't mean that they are the same in every respect! We know that and surely Epicurus did too, so we need to interpret him reasonably. E en to say that two people are experiencing 100% pleasure does not mean that they are doing or experiencing exactly the same thing -- which I would argue is the point of Cicero challenging Torquatus to defend how the host pouting wine could be experiencing the same pleasure as the guest drinking wine (in Book 2 of On Ends).

    Quote from Noah Calderon

    This is unfortunately very tricky to get a single clear answer on since we are not the hypothesized gods whose absolute diligence guarantees them 100% pleasure all of the time.

    Nor are we godlike in being able to say with omniscience that we know for sure which choices would lead to the "greatest pleasure" for us as humans. We can choose among the experiences we know or have access too, but it's not possible to say that XYZ combination of specific experiences equate to "happiness" or "our best life." "Happiness" or "Pure Pleasure" are concepts that can refer to any number of specific experiences in specific people.

    Quote from Noah Calderon

    in the literal sense that pleasure is complete when all pain is removed.

    Right - I think we take the words literally and that means considering all the possible meanings of the words and all the ways those words can be used. "Complete" certainly seems to have been intended to mean something specific, which isn't entirely clear (I would argue) unless you step back and try to understand that Platonists and others were concerned about "being" vs "becoming" and that something that is "becoming" is not "complete." I don't think that way of looking at things is of much use to most people, but for those who like logic games Epicurus giives a way out of the problem the Platonists think they see.,

Resources

  1. Getting Started At EpicureanFriends
  2. Community Standards And Posting Policies
  3. The Major Doctrines of Classical Epicurean Philosophy
  4. Introductory Videos
  5. Lexicon
  6. Lucretius Today Podcast
    1. Podcast Episode Guide
  7. Key Epicurean Texts
    1. Chart Of Key Quotes
    2. Outline Of Key Quotes
    3. Side-By-Side Diogenes Laertius X (Bio And All Key Writings of Epicurus)
    4. Side-By-Side Lucretius - On The Nature Of Things
    5. Side-By-Side Torquatus On Ethics
    6. Side-By-Side Velleius on Divinity
    7. Lucretius Topical Outline
    8. Usener Fragment Collection
  8. Frequently Asked Questions
    1. FAQ Discussions
  9. Full List of Forums
    1. Physics Discussions
    2. Canonics Discussions
    3. Ethics Discussions
    4. All Recent Forum Activities
  10. Image Gallery
  11. Featured Articles
  12. Featured Blog Posts
  13. Quiz Section
  14. Special Resource Pages
  15. File Database
  16. Site Map
    1. Home

Frequently Used Forums

  • Frequently Asked / Introductory Questions
  • News And Announcements
  • Lucretius Today Podcast
  • Physics (The Nature of the Universe)
  • Canonics (The Tests Of Truth)
  • Ethics (How To Live)
  • Against Determinism
  • Against Skepticism
  • The "Meaning of Life" Question
  • Uncategorized Discussion
  • Comparisons With Other Philosophies
  • Historical Figures
  • Ancient Writers and Texts
  • Decline of The Ancient Epicurean Age
  • Unsolved Questions of Epicurean History
  • Welcome New Participants
  • Events - Activism - Outreach
  • Full Forum List

Latest Posts

  1. Characteristics of an Epicurean Sage: A New Translation

    Cassius
    November 17, 2026 at 5:26 PM
  2. Video: "Before You Can Change Your World You Must Understand Your World"

    Cassius
    November 17, 2026 at 9:37 AM
  3. Video Launching 11/17/26 - "Before You Can Change Your World You Must Understand Your World"

    Cassius
    November 17, 2026 at 9:31 AM
  4. Under What Circumstances, If Any, Would An Epicurean Choose A Course That Produced (For Example) 98% Pleasure And 2% Pain Over A Course That Was 100% Pleasure and 0% Pain?

    Cassius
    November 17, 2026 at 8:41 AM
  5. Recommendations for Happy Living

    Kalosyni
    November 17, 2026 at 8:02 AM
  6. Welcome Demstar555!

    Cassius
    November 15, 2026 at 3:40 PM
  7. The Role Of Vortices (The Vortex) In The Creation Of Worlds - Part of the Epicurean Alternative To Intelligent Design

    Cassius
    November 14, 2026 at 3:58 PM
  8. Episode 360 - EATAQ42 - Continuing in Part 21 of Book 2 of Academic Questions - Not Yet Recorded

    Cassius
    November 14, 2026 at 1:44 PM
  9. New Article Attacking Epicurean Physics: "Science Versus the Oldest Anti-Intelligent Design Argument "

    Cassius
    November 13, 2026 at 11:52 AM
  10. Episode 359 - EATAQ41 - According To The Skeptics, Why Aim For The Truth When You Can GIve Up Trying To Be Right And Never Have To Admit That You're Wrong?

    Cassius
    November 12, 2026 at 3:24 PM

Frequently Used Tags

In addition to posting in the appropriate forums, participants are encouraged to reference the following tags in their posts:

  • #Physics
    • #Atomism
    • #Gods
    • #Images
    • #Infinity
    • #Eternity
    • #Life
    • #Death
  • #Canonics
    • #Knowledge
    • #Scepticism
  • #Ethics

    • #Pleasure
    • #Pain
    • #Engagement
    • #EpicureanLiving
    • #Happiness
    • #Virtue
      • #Wisdom
      • #Temperance
      • #Courage
      • #Justice
      • #Honesty
      • #Faith (Confidence)
      • #Suavity
      • #Consideration
      • #Hope
      • #Gratitude
      • #Friendship



Click Here To Search All Tags

To Suggest Additions To This List Click Here

EpicureanFriends - Classical Epicurean Philosophy

  1. Home
    1. About Us
    2. Classical Epicurean Philosophy
    3. Rules, Terms & Policies
  2. Lexicon
    1. Getting Started
  3. Frequently Asked Questions
    1. Site Map
  4. Forum
    1. Latest Threads
    2. Featured Threads
    3. Unread Posts
  5. Texts
    1. Core Texts
    2. Biography of Epicurus
    3. Lucretius
  6. Articles
    1. Latest Articles
  7. Gallery
    1. Featured Images
  8. Calendar
    1. This Month At EpicureanFriends
Powered by WoltLab Suite™ 6.2.9
Style: Inspire by cls-design
Stylename
Inspire
Manufacturer
cls-design
Licence
Commercial styles
Help
Supportforum
Visit cls-design