I believe that whether or not you get much pleasure from regularly engaging your social bonds is a matter of your nature, and there isn't necessarily anything wrong if you'd rather stay in and read a book instead of discoursing with your friends. Is it not correct to say that Epicurus advocated for friendship primarily because of the security it provides, giving you a guarantee that your necessary desires are always fulfilled (VS34). Therefore the acquisition of friends seems motivated primarily by this security which is a good place from which to start pursuing those natural desires that aren't harmful to us. We can also get much else from them, like the regular renewal of our understanding of the basics of the philosophy that prevents false opinions from ruining our happiness. But beyond this friends aren't intrinsically valuable unless spending time with them provides you with some kind of pleasure, which I assume for most people it definitely does. I imagine some asocial people might exist however for whom it isn't as pleasurable, and for whom a smaller circle of friends is preferable.
One thing that's interesting to me about this though is that some people are perhaps more insensitive to pleasure, but we're also more insensitive the more we get, so that at some point living lavishly and actively becomes costly both in terms of sustaining that pleasure and in terms of securing the necessities. I'm not sure if I understand: does Epicurus himself or his followers definitively believe that given human nature there are some things we can say the wise person does do with regards to pleasure. It seems the school was very much built around a retired sort of life. For example DeWitt writes in page 319:
"Under the head of Necessity fall the compulsions that ensue upon the pranks of Fortune, such as war, famine, and loss of property. Here too the secret of remaining happy is preparedness, which consists mainly in the simple, retired life."
Why does it seem to me like there's some judgement here being made between the pleasurableness of an active ambitious life with lots of different pleasures and the pleasurableness of a more passive simple life with less work put in, that I can't really see an explicit justification for existing since justifications are contingent on the time we live in and our own nature. Maybe today it's easier to live a less ascetic lifestyle without sacrificing that sense of security because a lot more people today (at least the ones living in developed countries) have more abundance (though perhaps not of the right things).
I apologize if I got carried away and switched to a different topic. I'm trying to test my understanding of the theory by writing about it.
Posts by Noah Calderon
-
-
This is a very difficult topic to wrap my head around. People are temperamentally different, which is to say that they are more sensitive to different kinds of pleasure and pain and a lot of that could be viewed as a completely standard interface with Nature, who provides us with pleasure and pain as signals for how to live our life. So when we talk about these things we can easily confuse concepts. So for instance does the unavoidable existence of a natural but unnecessary desire ruin the 100% pleasure involved in the safer route and therefore actually make it more painful than the more proactive 98% pleasure mixed with 2% pain route.
This is unfortunately very tricky to get a single clear answer on since we are not the hypothesized gods whose absolute diligence guarantees them 100% pleasure all of the time. We can only try to persuade our Nature. However if I were to settle on a philosophical framework that made communicating about these the easiest possible I would probably interpret PD3 in the literal sense that pleasure is complete when all pain is removed.
This question is very interesting, and I think the answer is in how we would define pleasure and pain, since that resolves the confusion in why we would ever "choose" pain. I am open to correction, though, since I am still studying. -
-
I live in a country (Finland) that consistently has very high levels of social trust and trust in government and other institutions. As a result, I do often feel at ease and confident in the future containing the same necessities for happiness that I have experienced in the past. I also have quite few close friends, to the point that I can see in practice very often the difference in my resilience to pain, sense of security, and enjoyment of pleasure when I am alone and when I am with friends. In my mind, I can separate these two sources of pleasure from social life, but they also feel very similar to me.
So when reading about Epicurus, I can see clearly the unique benefits of strong friendships on lifetime pleasure. One thing that I do not understand though is whether, in Epicurus' time, there was such a thing as "social trust" among communities larger than say, the Garden, and whether this is thought to possibly contribute to a similar sense of security. Is a sense of security drawn from strangers and political institutions less reliable and therefore a false opinion? I have the sense that modern egalitarian democracies that are resilient to corruption have achieved remarkable levels of trust and accountability from institutions and it is possible ancient societies could have been lacking in this department. I don't have the historical knowledge to say this with certainty, however.
Are there bounds to the concept of friendship in the sense thought of by Epicurus (the characteristics of it and the specific benefits it provides) that rule out other forms of kinship with human beings, kinds that do not even necessarily require knowing the other person? Thank you to anyone who understands what is confusing me here and can maybe point to some texts that elucidate the issue for me. -
Hello everyone and especially the mod team. I just wanted to add a post here because it has been a year (and I don't want to be mistaken as inactive, even though I haven't posted).
Over the past 12 months I have read Norman DeWitt's Epicurus and His Philosophy as well as Emily Austin's Living For Pleasure. The former was pretty dense and historical for me, but very informative. The latter gave me a pretty good reading list in the very beginning of all the texts which I ended up putting into a to-read list of sorts that I'm working through now. It was also very approachable.
Despite this I find it very difficult to find places where I can provide a valuable input on the forum. I feel like most of my questions will eventually be answered by reading more. I don't know if this is reasonable approach given the emphasis Epicurus placed on personal development through social bonds specifically, but I am quite shy.
Anyway, just wanted to say that this is still my philosophy of choice and I am enjoying the process of learning and growing my practical understanding of it.
Thank you for maintaining the forum! -
Thank you, Kalosyni. I ended up watching both of these and they were really insightful (especially the first one). It really does seem like there's a lot to get into.
The book I ordered is not among those recommended on this site, so I'll look into these other resources after I've finished it. Hopefully I begin to get a more holistic understanding beyond just the Ethics as time goes on.
-
Thanks, Cassius, for being so inviting. I will try to participate in discussions as I learn.
Also, I see you're from the Nordics too Rolf. I grew up with the series and you're right, that's something I felt in the character too. -
Hi all,
I'm young enough to have mostly missed the days of community-oriented forums like this one, but I was happy to find that one existed for this exciting new (or should I say old?) school of thought I have recently become quite interested in.
Some things about myself: I am from Finland, and am writing under a pseudonym. I have read the Letter to Menoeceus, and the Principal Doctrines, and some other material on the web. Having become interested, I ordered a book by one Catherine Wilson on the topic as applied to modern life, and in the meantime have especially struggled with what really constitutes a wise and rational pursuit of pleasure in life.
Speaking of, this is the primary reason I joined the forum and began reading about Epicurean philosophy. Having tried and failed to fit various competing but ultimately contrived value hierarchies into an ultimately nihilistic worldview I think I kind of settled on the conclusion that "If You Were Certain That There Are No Supernatural Gods And No Life After Death" you ought to make the most of life and stop clinging to ideals and imposed order and whatnot. How this is achieved is an art of its own, and upon looking into it, it seems that Epicurus and the school he founded got pretty far.Thanks! Hoping to learn a lot from all of you before I start posting, since I am still quite a novice.