If Jefferson had written the constitution I bet he wouldn't have made that grammatical slip!

The Importance Of The Perfect Not Being Allowed To Be The Enemy of The Good
Regularly Checking In On A Small Screen Device? Bookmark THIS page!
-
-
To form a more perfect Union
The phrase "to form a more perfect Union" has been construed as referring to the shift to the Constitution from the Articles of Confederation. The contemporaneous meaning of the word "perfect" was complete, finished, fully informed, confident, or certain. The phrase has been interpreted in various ways throughout history based on the context of the times. For example, shortly after the Civil War and the ratification of the Fourteenth Amendment, the Supreme Court said that the "Union" was made "more perfect" by the creation of a federal government with enough power to act directly upon citizens, rather than a government with narrowly limited power that could act on citizens only indirectly through the states, e.g., by imposing taxes. Also, the institution was created as a government over the States and people, not an agreement (union) between the States. -
The German translation "perfekt" has "perfekter" and "perfektester" and similar words as grammatically correct comparison forms but I do not recall any actual usage of those forms.
-
I seem to recall from the dim past of my schooling that I was taught that the "proper" forms are "more nearly perfect" and "most nearly perfect" leading up to perfect itself.
-
People, were talking the late 1700s here. Grammar is not what it used to be.
The whole idea with that phrase was that the Constitution would be "closer to being finished, more complete, more fully formed" than the wonky, loosey-goosey Articles of Confederation.
The Constitution, in the eyes of the Framers, made the United States of America closer to a real country rather than a conglomeration of individual states (ie, their own countries).
-
People, were talking the late 1700s here. Grammar is not what it used to be.
Absolutely. Not to flog a trivial point to death, but Latin also has/had comparative and superlative forms of perfectus:
https://www.latin-is-simple.com/en/vocabulary/adjective/6667/?h=perfectus
-
Tullius comes to the aid of the "perfect is not the enemy of the good" camp in our upcoming Lucretius Today episode 279. In discussing life span, he says at Tusculan Disputations 1:39
QuoteMen judge better in other things, and allow a part to be preferable to none; why do they not admit the same estimate in life?
At id quidem in ceteris rebus melius putatur, aliquam partem quam nullam attingere: cur in vita secus ?
OK more like ""But indeed in other matters, it is considered better to achieve some part than none at all: why is it different in life?"
It looks like the placement of the comma is questionable and ought to be deleted or moved:
At id quidem in ceteris rebus, melius putatur aliquam partem quam nullam attingere: cur in vita secus ?So the key Latin phrase is: melius putatur aliquam partem quam nullam attingere
better it is thought a large part, than none, to be achieved.
It also looks like both Yonge and Hicks are ignoring the aliquam and just saying "a part" - when the aliquam seems to indicate "a large part."
Here's nodictionaries.com:
aliquam partem quam nullam attingere, cur in vita secus ? aliquamlargely, to a large extent, a lot of nullus, nulla, nullum (gen -ius)no; none, not any attingo, attingere, attigi, attactustouch, touch/border on; reach, arrive at, achieve; mention briefly; belong to curwhy, wherefore; for what reason/purpose?; on account of which?; because vita, vitae Flife, career, livelihood; mode of life secus otherwise; differently, in another way; contrary to what is right/expected -
The "aliquam" from your list is the adverb "largely," --- which is not that common -- but in this sentence it is a version of aliquis and means "some."
"It is thought better to obtain some part rather than none [at all]."
-
Why do you use "some" instead of "largely"?
-
In the sentence we are looking at aliquam is an adjective, from aliquis and usually means "some."
Less common is the adverbial use of aliquam, and only there does it mean "somewhat, to some degree" which comes close to "largely."
https://www.perseus.tufts.edu/hopper/morph?l=aliquis&la=la#lexicon
"aliquis, indef. adj., some, any"
-
Unread Threads
-
- Title
- Replies
- Last Reply
-
-
-
Why pursue unnecessary desires? 17
- Rolf
May 2, 2025 at 12:41 PM - General Discussion
- Rolf
May 2, 2025 at 5:50 PM
-
- Replies
- 17
- Views
- 163
17
-
-
-
-
The Importance Of The Perfect Not Being Allowed To Be The Enemy of The Good 29
- Cassius
May 18, 2023 at 10:30 AM - General Discussion
- Cassius
May 2, 2025 at 11:44 AM
-
- Replies
- 29
- Views
- 5.9k
29
-
-
-
-
Must All Things That Have A Beginning Have An End? 10
- Cassius
May 1, 2025 at 9:48 AM - General Discussion
- Cassius
May 2, 2025 at 10:46 AM
-
- Replies
- 10
- Views
- 231
10
-
-
-
-
Considering Whether Epicurus Taught Both Exoteric and Esoteric Truths
- Cassius
May 1, 2025 at 5:33 PM - General Discussion
- Cassius
May 1, 2025 at 5:33 PM
-
- Replies
- 0
- Views
- 84
-
-
-
-
Epicurean Philosophy In Relation To Gulags and the Rack 6
- Cassius
April 26, 2025 at 2:25 PM - General Discussion
- Cassius
April 30, 2025 at 1:46 PM
-
- Replies
- 6
- Views
- 512
6
-