1. Home
    1. Study Guide
    2. Community Standards
    3. Site Map
    4. Quizzes
    5. Articles On Physics
    6. Articles On Canonics
    7. Articles On Ethics
    8. All Articles
    9. Elli's Blog Posts
    10. Kalosyni's Blog
    11. All Blog Posts
  2. Lexicon
    1. Lexicon Home
    2. FAQ
    3. Files
    4. Search Assistance
    5. Foundations
    6. Navigation Outlines
    7. Reading List
    8. Key Pages
    9. Last Changes
  3. Forum
    1. Full Forum List
    2. Welcome Threads
    3. Ancient Texts Forum
    4. Physics
    5. Canonics
    6. Ethics
    7. Forum Shortcuts
    8. Forum Navigation Map
    9. Featured
    10. Most Discussed
  4. Latest
    1. New Activity
    2. Latest Threads
    3. Dashboard
    4. Search By Tag
    5. Complete Tag List
  5. Podcast
    1. Lucretius Today Podcast
    2. Episode Guide
    3. Lucretius Today At Youtube
    4. EpicureanFriends Youtube Page
  6. Texts
    1. Overview
    2. Torquatus On Ethics
    3. Velleius On Divinity
    4. Diogenes Laertius
    5. Principal Doctrines
    6. Vatican Collection
    7. Lucretius
    8. Herodotus
    9. Pythocles
    10. Menoeceus
    11. Fragments - Usener Collection
    12. Greek/Latin Help
  7. Gallery
    1. Latest Images
    2. Featured images
    3. Latest Comments
  8. More
    1. Featured Content
    2. Logbook
    3. EF ToDo List
  • Login
  • Register
  • Search
This Thread
  • Everywhere
  • This Thread
  • This Forum
  • Forum
  • Articles
  • Blog Articles
  • Files
  • Gallery
  • Pages
  • Wiki
  • FAQ
  • More Options
  1. EpicureanFriends - Classical Epicurean Philosophy
  2. Forum
  3. Modern Books, Articles, and Videos
  4. Recommended Books
  5. Epicurus And His Philosophy - Norman DeWitt
  6. Epicurus and His Philosophy - Chapter Specific Threads

Reflections on chapter 11

  • SimonC
  • January 28, 2022 at 5:01 PM
  • Go to last post
  • SimonC
    2 - Guest Level 2
    Points
    276
    Posts
    37
    • January 28, 2022 at 5:01 PM
    • #1

    What an interesting chapter! I was not very familiar with this material before. I wonder how much of it is explicit in the sources and how much is DeWitt extrapolating though.

    Particularly impressive points as I understood them:

    - The need for soul atoms (ie the nervous system, sort of) to interact with the body to give rise to sensation. This makes sense to me even though it is apparently a controversial issue in current philosophy. But it does seem to follow from the physics.

    - The automatic vs intentional thinking, this is very perceptive psychology and also makes a lot of sense. It brings to mind the later dual process theory.

    - The courtroom analogy. Is this entirely DeWitt? Again very clarifying and brings context to "all sensations are true".

    I did not entirely grasp why it should be worse to think that Acheron might exist than to be sure that it does.

    I also wonder what evidence could have led Epicurus to claim that the rational soul is situated in the chest. The Stoics apparently also thought this so perhaps it was a cultural idea? Or because you die if you get stabbed there?

  • Don
    ΕΠΙΚΟΥΡΕΙΟΣ (Epicurist)
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    42,958
    Posts
    6,053
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    92.8 %
    • January 28, 2022 at 5:28 PM
    • #2
    Quote from SimonC

    I also wonder what evidence could have led Epicurus to claim that the rational soul is situated in the chest.

    Because that's where you "feel" many emotions, the metaphorical and literal "tightening of the chest." It's the same cultural idea we have vestiges of with words like "heart broken."

    There was a real debate in the ancient world of whether the mind was centered in the brain or the heart.

    FYI:

    Understanding Brain, Mind and Soul: Contributions from Neurology and Neurosurgery
    Treatment of diseases of the brain by drugs or surgery necessitates an understanding of its structure and functions. The philosophical neurosurgeon soon…
    www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov

    "Prioreschi (1996) concluded that by the end of the 5th century B.C., the question of whether the heart or the brain was the seat of intelligence remained unresolved in Western medicine. This changed with the works of Hippocrates (ca. 460 BC–ca. 370 BC)"

    Ancient Greek Philosophy and the Birth of Neuroscience
    We recognize today that the Ancient Greeks made significant achievements in mathematics, engineering, and astronomy, and that their achievements in these…
    thebrainscientist.com

    "We now think that the opposing view – cardiocentrism – is obviously wrong. But thinkers as prominent as Aristotle subscribed to this view. Why? One possible explanation is that these philosophers observed that when the heart stops beating, you die, and so they conjectured that the heart must control the mind. Many prominent ancient Greek physicians held this view, and indeed the debate between cardiocentrism and encephalocentrism continued well into the Renaissance."

  • Cassius
    5 - Administrator
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    116,117
    Posts
    16,001
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 28, 2022 at 6:42 PM
    • #3

    As far as the courtroom analogy on the "truth" of the senses as witnesses, I have never seen that developed anywhere else in my reading other than DeWitt. I too consider it to be very clarifying and likely correct and consistent with the texts. In my mind this is an example of some of DeWitt's major strengths. You may or may not agree with all his extrapolations but I think his sympathy with Epicurean positions and his attempt to find explanations that make sense are very refreshing. You'll have plenty of time in the future to get tired of those many commentators who are convinced that they are far smarter than Epicurus and like nothing more than to argue how naive Epicurus was. For all the faults that he may have, DeWitt makes an effort to reconstruct Epicurus in a sensible way.

  • Joshua
    5 - Administrator
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    15,627
    Posts
    2,013
    Quizzes
    3
    Quiz rate
    95.8 %
    • January 28, 2022 at 7:08 PM
    • #4

    The kernel of this idea is so pervasive even today, that it remains an argumentative ploy for the supernatural. How many best-selling books have been trafficked under the paradigm?

    "I was dead---" sometimes the word clinically or medically appears here, sometimes the word literally "---for 11 minutes and I went to heaven"---sometimes saw my past/future lives, or experienced the whole of being or some such. Generally the 'experience' is culturally and religiously dependant.

    Clinical death is misleading, precisely because it is not necessarily death. If you've come back to tell me what happened while you were dead, you weren't dead. Your brain yet lived.

    Interestingly, the brain was sometimes dealt with in a rather cavalier fashion in antiquity, not just in the Mediterranean but all around the world--in a procedure called trepanation, holes were drilled through the skull to relieve pressure or headaches, to release evil spirits, or to repair damage to the skull itself. Surprisingly, people actually sometimes survived!

    Then there is the story of the birth of Athena, clanking around in Zeus' head in a full suit of armor until he (Zeus) asked for it to be cracked open like an egg. Make of that what you will!

  • Don
    ΕΠΙΚΟΥΡΕΙΟΣ (Epicurist)
    • I Too Am An Epicurean
    • Advocate
    • Lucretius Today Podcast Co-Host
    • 2025 Contributor
    • Active Member 5 Years or more
    Points
    42,958
    Posts
    6,053
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    92.8 %
    • January 28, 2022 at 7:19 PM
    • #5
    Quote from Joshua

    Interestingly, the brain was sometimes dealt with in a rather cavalier fashion in antiquity

    Yeah, I still like the stories of the ancient Egyptian embalmers taking such care with the heart, placing it in its own canopic jar... Then sticking a hook up the nose and just yanking out the brain, chunk by chunk ^^

  • SimonC
    2 - Guest Level 2
    Points
    276
    Posts
    37
    • January 29, 2022 at 2:19 AM
    • #6
    Quote from Joshua

    "I was dead---" sometimes the word clinically or medically appears here, sometimes the word literally "---for 11 minutes and I went to heaven"---sometimes saw my past/future lives, or experienced the whole of being or some such. Generally the 'experience' is culturally and religiously dependant.

    Clinical death is misleading, precisely because it is not necessarily death. If you've come back to tell me what happened while you were dead, you weren't dead. Your brain yet lived.

    I agree, and we don't use that terminology in my country at all. If you live afterwards you weren't dead.

  • Marco
    3 - Friend
    Points
    461
    Posts
    57
    • January 29, 2022 at 4:48 AM
    • #7

    The reason of feelings like pain in the heart is Takotsubo cardiomyopathie.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Takotsubo_cardiomyopathy

  • Cassius March 13, 2025 at 9:54 AM

    Moved the thread from forum Chapter Eleven - Soul, Sensation, and Mind to forum Epicurus and His Philosophy - Chapter Specific Threads.

Resources

  1. Getting Started At EpicureanFriends
  2. Community Standards And Posting Policies
  3. The Major Doctrines of Classical Epicurean Philosophy
  4. Introductory Videos
  5. Lexicon
  6. Lucretius Today Podcast
    1. Podcast Episode Guide
  7. Key Epicurean Texts
    1. Chart Of Key Quotes
    2. Outline Of Key Quotes
    3. Side-By-Side Diogenes Laertius X (Bio And All Key Writings of Epicurus)
    4. Side-By-Side Lucretius - On The Nature Of Things
    5. Side-By-Side Torquatus On Ethics
    6. Side-By-Side Velleius on Divinity
    7. Lucretius Topical Outline
    8. Usener Fragment Collection
  8. Frequently Asked Questions
    1. FAQ Discussions
  9. Full List of Forums
    1. Physics Discussions
    2. Canonics Discussions
    3. Ethics Discussions
    4. All Recent Forum Activities
  10. Image Gallery
  11. Featured Articles
  12. Featured Blog Posts
  13. Quiz Section
  14. Special Resource Pages
  15. File Database
  16. Site Map
    1. Home

Frequently Used Forums

  • Frequently Asked / Introductory Questions
  • News And Announcements
  • Lucretius Today Podcast
  • Physics (The Nature of the Universe)
  • Canonics (The Tests Of Truth)
  • Ethics (How To Live)
  • Against Determinism
  • Against Skepticism
  • The "Meaning of Life" Question
  • Uncategorized Discussion
  • Comparisons With Other Philosophies
  • Historical Figures
  • Ancient Writers and Texts
  • Decline of The Ancient Epicurean Age
  • Unsolved Questions of Epicurean History
  • Welcome New Participants
  • Events - Activism - Outreach
  • Full Forum List

Latest Posts

  1. Catius' Cat Website / Poems / Videos

    Kalosyni
    November 21, 2026 at 7:34 AM
  2. New Article: Almost Is Not Nothing: The All-Or-Nothing Error From Plato To "Almost Persuaded," And How Epicurus Answered It

    Cassius
    November 21, 2026 at 6:50 AM
  3. Discussion of Article - "Almost Is Not Nothing: The All-Or-Nothing Error From Plato To "Almost Persuaded," And How Epicurus Answered It"

    Cassius
    November 21, 2026 at 6:46 AM
  4. Discussion of Article - "One Wise Man Is Not Wiser Than Another: What Epicurus' Saying Tells Us About Pleasure, Happiness, And How We Know What Is Real"

    Cassius
    November 20, 2026 at 9:28 PM
  5. Episode 360 - EATAQ42 - Should We Refrain From Having An Opinion On Anything At All Because We Might Be Wrong?

    Cassius
    November 20, 2026 at 9:23 PM
  6. World's Worst Epicurus Videos

    Cassius
    November 20, 2026 at 3:30 PM
  7. Happy Twentieth of November 2026!

    Kalosyni
    November 20, 2026 at 9:31 AM
  8. Recommendations for Happy Living

    Bryan
    November 19, 2026 at 10:48 PM
  9. Is One Wise Man Wiser Than Another? Why Did Epicurus Answer "No"?

    Cassius
    November 19, 2026 at 9:33 AM
  10. New Article: One Wise Man Is Not Wiser Than Another: What Epicurus' Saying Tells Us About Pleasure, Happiness, And How We Know What Is Real

    Cassius
    November 19, 2026 at 9:23 AM

Frequently Used Tags

In addition to posting in the appropriate forums, participants are encouraged to reference the following tags in their posts:

  • #Physics
    • #Atomism
    • #Gods
    • #Images
    • #Infinity
    • #Eternity
    • #Life
    • #Death
  • #Canonics
    • #Knowledge
    • #Scepticism
  • #Ethics

    • #Pleasure
    • #Pain
    • #Engagement
    • #EpicureanLiving
    • #Happiness
    • #Virtue
      • #Wisdom
      • #Temperance
      • #Courage
      • #Justice
      • #Honesty
      • #Faith (Confidence)
      • #Suavity
      • #Consideration
      • #Hope
      • #Gratitude
      • #Friendship



Click Here To Search All Tags

To Suggest Additions To This List Click Here

EpicureanFriends - Classical Epicurean Philosophy

  1. Home
    1. About Us
    2. Classical Epicurean Philosophy
    3. Rules, Terms & Policies
  2. Lexicon
    1. Getting Started
  3. Frequently Asked Questions
    1. Site Map
  4. Forum
    1. Latest Threads
    2. Featured Threads
    3. Unread Posts
  5. Texts
    1. Core Texts
    2. Biography of Epicurus
    3. Lucretius
  6. Articles
    1. Latest Articles
  7. Gallery
    1. Featured Images
  8. Calendar
    1. This Month At EpicureanFriends
Powered by WoltLab Suite™ 6.2.9
Style: Inspire by cls-design
Stylename
Inspire
Manufacturer
cls-design
Licence
Commercial styles
Help
Supportforum
Visit cls-design