This thread is for discussion of the video launching today: "Before You Can Change Your World You Must Understand Your World"
Video: "Before You Can Change Your World You Must Understand Your World"
-
-
A full transcript of the video script is here:
Before You Can Change Your World, You Must Understand Your WorldA short video, with its full script and slides: ten charges brought against Epicurus by rival philosophies and religions, and how Epicurus answered each one.epicurustoday.com -
This is so good! But it would be better to see you sitting at your desk, making this argument Andy Rooney style.
-
Interesting presentation of the charges against Epicurus.
The closing appears to highlight the argument and set forward a challenge that divides (are you with us or against us).
QuoteYou Be the Judge
These are the major charges. What do you believe, and do you consider yourself a friend or an enemy of Epicurus’ views? If you agree with Epicurus, we invite you to join us in the study of his philosophy at EpicureanFriends.com.
Please reconsider this ending that currently sets up an excluding divide, and could be more effective with an inclusive invitation to learn more about Epicurean philosophy. How can a person who first hears about Epicurus from this video know whether they are an enemy of Epicurus’ views or not. A summary like this could be more palatable.Quote"You be the judge.
We have examined the major charges leveled against Epicurus, and we invite you to weigh these arguments for yourself. Whether you find yourself in full agreement with his views or are simply curious to explore a different perspective on how to live a life of pleasure and meaning, we welcome you to join us. Our community at EpicureanFriends.com is a place for open, thoughtful study, where we test our understanding against the ancient texts and against each other. We invite you to bring your questions and join us in the ongoing pursuit of a life well-lived." -
Thanks for the comments. There may be ways to implement what you are suggesting but it will take separate efforts. I see the primary purpose of the forum to be collaboration among people who are already agreed on the points in the video, which are very basic and clear. I theregore don't want to go too far in the direction of suggesting that we are like Reddit and welcome everyone to participate no matter what their viewpoint.
The atmosphere at Reddit (for example) is very different from here, even though both serve legitimate purposes. The role of Epicrureanfriends is a place to collaborate with those who want to reconstruct the ancient school version of the philosophy on its own terms.
That can't be done effectively if all opinions and perspectives are equally welcome. We can wish everyone well without inviting them into the effort as equally valid positions, because many of them are simply incompatible.
Lots to discuss and think about on this topic.
-
The role of Epicrureanfriends is a place to collaborate with those who want to reconstruct the ancient school version of the philosophy on its own terms.
We’ll, pardon me for making a suggestion to move away from divisive language.
According to my reading of “A Few Days in Athens”, the ancient school did welcome those who were curious and interested to learn more, before they truly understood the complex Epicurean principles. And some students studied at other schools while coming to the Garden, as they sought to fully grasp the truth of each philosophy.
That’s why I joined EpicureanFriends, to learn more about how the Epicurean principles are being applied today, before I could state my full understanding of whether I should want to learn, memorize and apply all the KDs & VSs, and to be able to state to others that I consider myself to be a friend of Epicurus. I came here to learn and make Epicurean Friends, in a welcoming environment. But, maybe I misunderstood just how exclusionary this EF platform is trying to be. So, I’ll stop commenting for awhile.