1. New
    1. Member Announcements
  2. Home
    1. Get Started - Activities
    2. Posting Policies
    3. Community Standards
    4. Terms of Use
    5. Moderator Team
    6. Site Map
    7. Quizzes
    8. Articles
      1. Featured Articles
      2. Blog Posts at EpicureanFriends
  3. Wiki
    1. Wiki Home
    2. FAQ
    3. Classical Epicureanism
    4. Physics
    5. Canonics
    6. Ethics
    7. Search Assistance
    8. Not NeoEpicurean
    9. Foundations
    10. Navigation Outlines
    11. Key Pages
  4. Forum
    1. New Activity
    2. New Threads
    3. Welcome
    4. General Discussion
    5. Featured
    6. Activism
    7. Shortcuts
    8. Dashboard
    9. Full Forum List
    10. Level 3+
    11. Most Discussed
  5. Podcast
    1. Lucretius Today Podcast
    2. Episode Guide
    3. Lucretius Today At Youtube
    4. EpicureanFriends Youtube Page
  6. Texts
    1. Overview
    2. Diogenes Laertius
    3. Principal Doctrines
    4. Vatican Sayings
    5. Lucretius
    6. Herodotus
    7. Pythocles
    8. Menoeceus
    9. Fragments - Usener Collection
    10. Torquatus On Ethics
    11. Velleius On Gods
    12. Greek/Latin Help
  7. Gallery
    1. Featured images
    2. Albums
    3. Latest Images
    4. Latest Comments
  8. Calendar
    1. Upcoming Events List
    2. Zoom Meetings
    3. This Month
    4. First Monday Zoom Meetings
    5. Wednesday Zoom Meeting
    6. Twentieth Zoom Meetings
    7. Zoom Meetings
  9. Other
    1. Featured Content
    2. Blog Posts
    3. Files
    4. Logbook
    5. EF ToDo List
    6. Link-Database
  • Login
  • Register
  • Search
This Thread
  • Everywhere
  • This Thread
  • This Forum
  • Forum
  • Articles
  • Blog Articles
  • Files
  • Gallery
  • Events
  • Pages
  • Wiki
  • Help
  • FAQ
  • More Options

Welcome To EpicureanFriends.com!

"Remember that you are mortal, and you have a limited time to live, and in devoting yourself to discussion of the nature of time and eternity you have seen things that have been, are now, and are to come."

Sign In Now
or
Register a new account
  1. New
    1. Member Announcements
  2. Home
    1. Get Started - Activities
    2. Posting Policies
    3. Community Standards
    4. Terms of Use
    5. Moderator Team
    6. Site Map
    7. Quizzes
    8. Articles
      1. Featured Articles
      2. Blog Posts at EpicureanFriends
  3. Wiki
    1. Wiki Home
    2. FAQ
    3. Classical Epicureanism
    4. Physics
    5. Canonics
    6. Ethics
    7. Search Assistance
    8. Not NeoEpicurean
    9. Foundations
    10. Navigation Outlines
    11. Key Pages
  4. Forum
    1. New Activity
    2. New Threads
    3. Welcome
    4. General Discussion
    5. Featured
    6. Activism
    7. Shortcuts
    8. Dashboard
    9. Full Forum List
    10. Level 3+
    11. Most Discussed
  5. Podcast
    1. Lucretius Today Podcast
    2. Episode Guide
    3. Lucretius Today At Youtube
    4. EpicureanFriends Youtube Page
  6. Texts
    1. Overview
    2. Diogenes Laertius
    3. Principal Doctrines
    4. Vatican Sayings
    5. Lucretius
    6. Herodotus
    7. Pythocles
    8. Menoeceus
    9. Fragments - Usener Collection
    10. Torquatus On Ethics
    11. Velleius On Gods
    12. Greek/Latin Help
  7. Gallery
    1. Featured images
    2. Albums
    3. Latest Images
    4. Latest Comments
  8. Calendar
    1. Upcoming Events List
    2. Zoom Meetings
    3. This Month
    4. First Monday Zoom Meetings
    5. Wednesday Zoom Meeting
    6. Twentieth Zoom Meetings
    7. Zoom Meetings
  9. Other
    1. Featured Content
    2. Blog Posts
    3. Files
    4. Logbook
    5. EF ToDo List
    6. Link-Database
  1. New
    1. Member Announcements
  2. Home
    1. Get Started - Activities
    2. Posting Policies
    3. Community Standards
    4. Terms of Use
    5. Moderator Team
    6. Site Map
    7. Quizzes
    8. Articles
      1. Featured Articles
      2. Blog Posts at EpicureanFriends
  3. Wiki
    1. Wiki Home
    2. FAQ
    3. Classical Epicureanism
    4. Physics
    5. Canonics
    6. Ethics
    7. Search Assistance
    8. Not NeoEpicurean
    9. Foundations
    10. Navigation Outlines
    11. Key Pages
  4. Forum
    1. New Activity
    2. New Threads
    3. Welcome
    4. General Discussion
    5. Featured
    6. Activism
    7. Shortcuts
    8. Dashboard
    9. Full Forum List
    10. Level 3+
    11. Most Discussed
  5. Podcast
    1. Lucretius Today Podcast
    2. Episode Guide
    3. Lucretius Today At Youtube
    4. EpicureanFriends Youtube Page
  6. Texts
    1. Overview
    2. Diogenes Laertius
    3. Principal Doctrines
    4. Vatican Sayings
    5. Lucretius
    6. Herodotus
    7. Pythocles
    8. Menoeceus
    9. Fragments - Usener Collection
    10. Torquatus On Ethics
    11. Velleius On Gods
    12. Greek/Latin Help
  7. Gallery
    1. Featured images
    2. Albums
    3. Latest Images
    4. Latest Comments
  8. Calendar
    1. Upcoming Events List
    2. Zoom Meetings
    3. This Month
    4. First Monday Zoom Meetings
    5. Wednesday Zoom Meeting
    6. Twentieth Zoom Meetings
    7. Zoom Meetings
  9. Other
    1. Featured Content
    2. Blog Posts
    3. Files
    4. Logbook
    5. EF ToDo List
    6. Link-Database
  1. EpicureanFriends - Home of Classical Epicurean Philosophy
  2. Forum
  3. Physics - The Nature Of The Universe
  4. Nothing Can Be Created From Nothing - Nothing Can Be Destroyed To Nothing
  • Sidebar
  • Sidebar

"Nothing Comes from Nothing" and Parmenides

  • Matt
  • January 21, 2021 at 9:00 AM
  • Go to last post
Regularly Checking In On A Small Screen Device? Bookmark THIS page!
  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:00 AM
    • #1

    Nothing comes from nothing...this is surely getting deep now.

    I feel Parmenides bursting out saying “this is my thing folks!”

    “And it’s my thing because my “thing” is something, and that which is no “thing” cannot be since some “thing”already is. Nothing cannot be!”

    I believe Parmenides held that the universe must always be, because it exists. If nothing existed, there would be no universe. But since something “is” then nothing cannot be.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:07 AM
    • #2

    I guess it stands to “reason” that all things come from something. Even creation in the biblical sense and in many other myths is not truly ex nihilo.

    “In the beginning (pre-existing object) created the heaven and the earth.”

    All things must have previously existed from eternity. Based on Parmenidean principles...if the universe exists it exists from eternity (in whatever form). And since something DOES exist, since even one atom exists, the concept of nothing is upended.

    This is not to say that void does not exist, void and nothing are conceptually different. Void conceptually is the “space” between “things”.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:24 AM
    • #3

    Should I move my something and nothing comments to a new thread? I could legitimately discuss this all day.

  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:31 AM
    • #4

    Yes Matt I think that would be a good idea. The Something From Nothing issue is definitely an example of what we are talking about, but if we focus on it too much it might get the thread off track. It certainly deserves a thread of its own. I will take care of it now.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:34 AM
    • #5

    Awesome! Thanks!

  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:35 AM
    • #6

    Maybe more elaborate title for the thread Matt? What would you suggest? Post it here and I will make the change and then delete some of these housekeeping comments.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:37 AM
    • #7

    “Nothing comes from Nothing and Parmenides” as the title?

  • Cassius January 21, 2021 at 9:40 AM

    Changed the title of the thread from “Something From Nothing” to “"Nothing Comes from Nothing" and Parmenides”.
  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:42 AM
    • #8

    So is Parmenides the one who advocated a "plenum" and that there is no such thing as void? Or is this more of a formal logical proof? And if so, of what?

    If you're really into this Matt and would like to explain the background to those of us who don't know, that would be a good use of this thread in the forum. Whether it would be a good use of your time might be another question ;) But if you'd enjoy writing it I feel sure that some of us would benefit from / enjoy reading your summary of it.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:47 AM
    • #9

    I believe it had to do with a general ontological concept of the eternity of the universe.

    That if nothing truly existed, there would be no universe. But since something is… And we know that for a fact, nothing cannot be. Had nothing “existed”, nothing would ever be.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:48 AM
    • #10

    He may have gone on to try to disprove void, I actually don’t know if that’s true, I’d have to look it up. He may have.

    But for my purposes I see this as an important thought experiment for recognizing the eternity of the material universe.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:52 AM
    • #11

    I think Aristotle said that Parmenides ideas were “at the doorstep of madness.” But really discussing NO-thing and Something is important to Epicurean ideas.

  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 9:58 AM
    • #12
    Quote from Matt

    But for my purposes I see this as an important thought experiment for recognizing the eternity of the material universe.

    And at the very least Parmenides represents (as I understand it) one of the major views at the time of Epicurus, so his students would have been aware of it and thus some of his positions may be directed at it -- we can't recognize that if we don't know what Parmenides argued.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:02 AM
    • #13

    I’ll go see if I can find some good information on Parmenides the post here.

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:08 AM
    • #14

    https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nothing_comes_from_nothing

    The idea that "nothing comes from nothing", as articulated by Parmenides, first appears in Aristotle's Physics:


    τί δ᾽ ἄν μιν καὶ χρέος ὦρσεν ὕστερον ἢ πρόσθεν, τοῦ μηδενὸς ἀρξάμενον, φῦν; οὕτως ἢ πάμπαν πελέναι χρεών ἐστιν ἢ οὐχί.
    [1]

    The above, in a translation based on the John Burnet translation, appears as follows:

    “Yet why would it be created later rather than sooner, if it came from nothing; so, it must either be created altogether or not [created at all].”
  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:10 AM
    • #15

    Karl Popper wrote:

    “So what was really new in Parmenides was his axiomatic-deductive method, which Leucippus and Democritus turned into a hypothetical-deductive method, and thus made part of scientific methodology.”

  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:18 AM
    • #16

    It seems to me that Epicurus/Lucretius' version is clearly enough based at least in part on the observation that we do not see things being created from nothing, and therefore there is no reason to think that anything could be created from nothing by a god or by any other means. This kind of reasoning is discussed fairly clearly if I recall in "On Methods of Inference." To me that whole chain of reasoning is a fairly understandable inference of a deduction based on that which has been observed to be true. It's not just an assertion based on logic but one that is grounded in observation for it's persuasiveness.

    I don't see Parmenides' version being in the same league as it does not seem to be based on observation - or is it? Matt can you reword it into something more plain?

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:19 AM
    • #17

    And yes he apparently did try to argue that void was nothing and nothing is not possible, but I would contend that purely from a conceptual standpoint on the existence of the universe, his position of something “being” as opposed to nothing ever being...is sound. In my mind at least.

    I don’t see conceptually how anything comes from nothing...

    If we are talking about physics like vacuum fluctuation states etc. you are still talking about a “concept” a thing born of something. It’s still not NO-thing since it is a concept. Nothing cannot be a concept.

  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:21 AM
    • #18
    Quote from Matt

    but I would contend that purely from a conceptual standpoint on the existence of the universe, his position of something “being” as opposed to nothing ever being...is sound. In my mind at least.

    But when you say it is sound it IS purely "word-play" based on definitions -- or No? Is any "observation" involved?

  • Matt
    03 - Member
    Points
    2,974
    Posts
    426
    Quizzes
    4
    Quiz rate
    88.9 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:21 AM
    • #19

    Parmenides clearly was basing his argument on logical, not observable grounds.

  • Online
    Cassius
    05 - Administrator
    Points
    101,593
    Posts
    13,904
    Quizzes
    9
    Quiz rate
    100.0 %
    • January 21, 2021 at 10:22 AM
    • #20

    Ha ha -- this is where I would think we would be better off saying "formal logical grounds" or "abstract logical grounds" because what you are saying is that he is relying on logic (word-play; concepts) alone without any evidence, correct?

Unread Threads

    1. Title
    2. Replies
    3. Last Reply
    1. Is All Desire Painful? How Would Epicurus Answer? 13

      • Like 1
      • Cassius
      • May 7, 2025 at 10:02 PM
      • General Discussion
      • Cassius
      • May 9, 2025 at 5:11 AM
    2. Replies
      13
      Views
      304
      13
    3. Don

      May 9, 2025 at 5:11 AM
    1. Pompeii Then and Now 7

      • Like 2
      • kochiekoch
      • January 22, 2025 at 1:19 PM
      • General Discussion
      • kochiekoch
      • May 8, 2025 at 3:50 PM
    2. Replies
      7
      Views
      1k
      7
    3. kochiekoch

      May 8, 2025 at 3:50 PM
    1. Names of Bits of Reality 4

      • Thanks 2
      • Eikadistes
      • May 8, 2025 at 12:12 PM
      • General Discussion
      • Eikadistes
      • May 8, 2025 at 1:31 PM
    2. Replies
      4
      Views
      142
      4
    3. Eikadistes

      May 8, 2025 at 1:31 PM
    1. ⟐ as the symbol of the philosophy of Epicurus 15

      • Like 1
      • michelepinto
      • March 18, 2021 at 11:59 AM
      • General Discussion
      • michelepinto
      • May 8, 2025 at 1:20 PM
    2. Replies
      15
      Views
      6.6k
      15
    3. Don

      May 8, 2025 at 1:20 PM
    1. Why pursue unnecessary desires? 74

      • Like 1
      • Rolf
      • May 2, 2025 at 12:41 PM
      • General Discussion
      • Rolf
      • May 8, 2025 at 12:17 AM
    2. Replies
      74
      Views
      1.9k
      74
    3. Joshua

      May 8, 2025 at 12:17 AM

Latest Posts

  • Is All Desire Painful? How Would Epicurus Answer?

    Don May 9, 2025 at 5:11 AM
  • Pompeii Then and Now

    kochiekoch May 8, 2025 at 3:50 PM
  • Names of Bits of Reality

    Eikadistes May 8, 2025 at 1:31 PM
  • ⟐ as the symbol of the philosophy of Epicurus

    Don May 8, 2025 at 1:20 PM
  • Episode 280 - Wrapping Up Cicero's Arguments On Death

    Cassius May 8, 2025 at 11:54 AM
  • Episode 279 - On "Dying Before One's Time"

    Cassius May 8, 2025 at 11:15 AM
  • Why pursue unnecessary desires?

    Joshua May 8, 2025 at 12:17 AM
  • Author and Title of a Herculaneum Scroll Read

    kochiekoch May 7, 2025 at 9:45 PM
  • Welcome DaveT

    DaveT May 6, 2025 at 1:51 PM
  • First Picture of "Free Range Atoms"

    Cassius May 6, 2025 at 7:15 AM

EpicureanFriends - Classical Epicurean Philosophy

  1. Home
    1. About Us
    2. Classical Epicurean Philosophy
  2. Wiki
    1. Getting Started
  3. Frequently Asked Questions
    1. Site Map
  4. Forum
    1. Latest Threads
    2. Featured Threads
    3. Unread Posts
  5. Texts
    1. Core Texts
    2. Biography of Epicurus
    3. Lucretius
  6. Articles
    1. Latest Articles
  7. Gallery
    1. Featured Images
  8. Calendar
    1. This Month At EpicureanFriends
Powered by WoltLab Suite™ 6.0.22
Style: Inspire by cls-design
Stylename
Inspire
Manufacturer
cls-design
Licence
Commercial styles
Help
Supportforum
Visit cls-design