Posts by Thomas Karion
-
-
Thanks for your insightful message, Cassius.
1/ As for boredom, I’m not feeling it right now, so it’ll be hard for me to talk about it at length. But I imagine I must have been “unconsciously” troubled by something.
2/ Regarding health as experienced by a conscious being, I understand better what you mean.
3/ Regarding the fact that you “interpret (…) pleasure and pain as being felt simultaneously, but in different places, with the pleasure of the mind outweighing the pain of the body.” I understand that, too. But as you so aptly put it through Torquatus’s words: “A man conscious of his condition necessarily experiences either pleasure or pain.” So to me, it’s clear that a conscious man experiences either pleasure or pain, but not both at the same time. What do you think, Cassius?
4/ As for chronic pain, I think that’s a different subject. KD4 simply states that the pain of certain illnesses is inevitable but still bearable.
I look forward to hearing from you!
-
Hello Cassius,
I just read your text, which I found very interesting.
1. My Own Situation
To start with my own situation, I think I don’t feel pleasure because I feel a bit of boredom, however slight it may be.
Consequently, I’m not in a neutral state but in a state of slight unease that prevents me from feeling pleasure. I feel like something is missing. It’s true that I’m currently reevaluating how I manage my own desires and learning to moderate them. And I think this is starting to pay off, even though I believe I can still do a little better.
2. The Concepts of “Consciousness” and “Attention” in Epicurean Philosophy
You talk a lot about the concepts of “consciousness” and “attention.”
You write: “If you are conscious and there is no pain or suffering, you experience pleasure.”
And also: “We generally pay little attention to easy breathing as long as it remains steady. We barely notice a stomach that is functioning normally until nausea sets in. We pay little attention to our ability to sit, walk, see, think, or converse as long as any of these functions do not become painful or impaired. (…) Attention and contrast have changed; the body’s condition remains pleasant and unimpeded.
Or: “There is also a difference between having an experience and paying reflective attention to it.”
Or: “At this very moment, you may not be paying attention to the comfort of your breathing (…). Your attention may be focused on the abstract question: ‘Am I experiencing pleasure?’”
Could you provide me with some sources from Epicurean philosophy that address these concepts of “consciousness” and “attention”? Because I get the impression that, from your perspective, pleasure lies in the awareness of being in good health rather than: pleasure lies directly in the fact of being in good health.
3. Is it possible to feel pleasure and pain at the same time?
Second point: you write, “It is entirely possible to experience both pleasure and pain, and to do so in different ways. ”
Isn’t this incompatible with KD3, which states: “Wherever there is that which feels pleasure, as long as it exists, there is not that which is suffering, afflicted, or both”?
Epicurus writes: “I am writing these words to you on this happy day, which is also the last of my life. […] All my suffering is offset by the joy I find in the memory of our past conversations. ”
To me, this means that Epicurus feels pleasure rather than pain at the same time. I’m not denying that the pain is present, but I mean that the memory of those past conversations brings him pleasure and therefore prevents him from feeling the pain.
Do you have any Epicurean sources that could shed light on this topic for me?
Thank you very much in advance, Cassius!
Have a great day!!
-
Here is a draft synthesis of what you will find in much greater detail in the references listed above:
https://www.epicureanfriends.com/wcf/faq-questi…as-of-10-29-26/
Thanks, Cassius, for the FAQ. I'm going to play tennis, but I can't wait to read it as soon as I get back!
-
Thanks, Cassius. I’ve found the answer to my question. If I don’t feel pleasure, it’s indeed because I’m experiencing suffering, however slight it may be. I don’t have any other questions for now, but I won’t hesitate to post here as soon as I do. I think that’s actually one of the key points of Epicurus’s philosophy. Many people think they’re in a neutral state when in fact they’re experiencing suffering without realizing it, however slight it may be. But that’s another topic we may have the chance to discuss. In any case, I’ve found the answer to my question, and I thank you for your comment 🙂
-
Are you perhaps referring to “pleasures in motion” and “catastematic pleasure”?
Or perhaps simply to the fact that either pleasure or suffering exists?
-
Ok, thank you !
-
I have a second question.
In his third important maxim, Epicurus says that the removal of all suffering is the limit of the magnitude of pleasures.
Now, I am not experiencing any fear, physical pain, or mental distress at this moment.
However, I am not feeling any pleasure right now.
From an Epicurean perspective, can you explain why?
-
Thank you Kalosyni.
So I'll keep posting in this thread.
-
Welcome Thomas!
Thank you Martin !
-
Thank you Kalosyni !
-
Hello,
I have a question. I’m not sure if this is the right forum, or even if I’m in the right section of the forum. I hope you’ll forgive me if that’s the case.
My question is this:
What do you think Epicurus would write about today if he were alive in our time?
I’ve calculated that Epicurus wrote mostly on physics, particularly in his work *On Nature* (37 books, according to Diogenes Laertius), and then about (or for) his many friends (especially in his numerous letters). He also wrote on ethics and on the Canon (if we separate it from physics, contrary to common practice, I believe). Finally, I don’t think he wrote much (if at all) on politics.
“[Epicurus] wrote (…) some three hundred books, and he never quoted other authors—every word they contained was Epicurus’s own.” (Diogenes Laertius)
Here is a rough summary of the books written by the Epicureans of Epicurus’s time:
- On and for friends (22 books out of 93, or 25%): Chaeredemus / Neocles, dedicated to Themistus / Eurylochus, dedicated to Metrodorus / Aristobulus / Timocrates, in three books / Metrodorus, in five books / Antidorus, in two books / Callistolas / Anaximenes / Polymers / Hegesianax / Letters / Collections of Letters (H) / On the Disciples (H) / Exhortation to Study Philosophy / Principal Doctrines
- On the Canon (5 books out of 93, or 6%): On the Criterion, or the Canon / On Sensory Perception / On Vision / On the Sense of Touch / On Images / On Sensations (M)
- On Physics (39 books out of 93, or 44%): On Nature, in Thirty-Seven Books / On Atoms and the Void / On the Angle of the Atom / Summary of the Books for Physicists
- On Ethics (19 books out of 93, or 22%): On the Ultimate Goal / Theories on Diseases [and Death], Dedicated to the Mithras / On the Gods / On Holiness / On Choices and Avoiding Evil / On Gifts and Gratitude / On the Course of Life, in Four Books / On Fair Treatment / Symposium / On Music / On Justice and the Other Virtues / On Fate / On Kingship / On Love / On the Passions, Against Timocrates / On Magnanimity (M) / On Epicurus’s Weak Constitution (M) / On the Path to Wisdom (M) / On Change (M) / On Wealth (M) / On Nobility (M)
- Others (3 books out of 93, or 3%): Against the Megarians / Problems / Prognosis / Against the Physicians, three books (M) / Against Timocrates (M) / Against the Dialecticians (M) / Against the Sophists, 9 books (M) / Against Democritus (M) / On Empedocles, twenty-two books (H) / Against Plato (H) / Against Aristotle (H)
Furthermore, Maxime Capitale 11 states: “If doubts about celestial realities did not trouble us at all—nor those concerning death, which we fear may one day have something to do with us—or even the fact that we do not fully understand the limits of pain and desire, we would have no need to study nature. ”
Physics (particularly concerning nature)
If I were to attempt an approximate and unsatisfactory answer myself, I would begin by saying that, these days, most people seem to me to be less troubled by what he calls celestial realities (particularly the gods) and death. Because of this, I imagine that if Epicurus were to write books about nature today, it would be primarily to fully understand the limits of pain and desire (especially in the capitalist society of overconsumption in which we live). Furthermore, Epicurus would write about the Canon.
Friends
Furthermore, I think that if Epicurus were alive today, he would, of course, write a great deal about and for his friends.
Ethics
Regarding ethics, I think (if I were to revisit his ancient writings) that Epicurus would write about pleasure, of course, as well as about illness, choices and what to avoid, gifts and gratitude, life journeys, fair treatment, music, justice and other virtues, love, passions, wealth, and so on.
Gemini
I asked Gemini what it thought about this. It replied that, in light of our 21st century, Epicurus would focus his reflections on the following areas:
- The tyranny of algorithms and the attention crisis (endless scrolling, the quest for validation through “likes,” etc.)
- Overconsumption and capitalism
- New forms of anxiety (eco-anxiety and AI)
- Modern loneliness and the redefinition of friendship
- Quantum physics and neuroscience
That’s my modest contribution—and that of the AI. I’d love to hear your thoughts on this question:
What do you think Epicurus would write about today if he were alive in our time?
Thank you!