So it's out -- and I see the photo on the cover is Epicurus looking down as if he is depressed or downtrodden or otherwise exhausted. Well we know this was coming....
Posts by Cassius
-
-
There are a lot of excellent quotations in Sextus Empiricus which I had an idea existed but had never seen in context. The point of this introduction is to organize those and provide links to them to make them easier to read in context. I also added this to a PDF and the links in the PDF resolve to the PDF version, ad that one contains a full set of Bury's footnotes.
-
This thread is for discussion of the article:
ArticleSextus Empiricus - Introduction From An Epicurean Perspective
Sextus Empiricus and Epicurus both spoke of ataraxia, and many readers conclude that the two wanted the same thing. Sextus's own words show how far apart they are: he names Epicurus a Dogmatist, reaches his "quietude" by giving up on truth, and attacks the pleasure Epicurus made the goal of life. A guide to Sextus's surviving works and the passages that matter to Epicureans.
CassiusOctober 26, 2026 at 1:03 PM -
Something else I was not aware of - Socratic roots of seeing god as omniscient and ominpotent - page 83
QuoteIn Socrates the two modes of thought—the religious and the scientific—move
apart, not in the sense that they become in any way incompatible, but in
that Xenophon’s Socrates on the one hand advocates the cultivation of proper
religious attitudes as morally indispensable, but on the other strongly advises against the study of physics at a theoretical level. Appreciation of god’s
special care for mankind in no way depends on theorizing about just how
his gifts have been engineered.In so far as the Socrates we meet in the pages of Xenophon permits himself any theoretical speculation in this domain, it is with regard to theology. Once freed of physics, theological theory is permitted to remain on the agenda. Thus Socrates is ready to propound a specific argument that the world possesses intelligence (the “Cosmic Intelligence Argument,” to whichI shall return in chapter VII §3). And he attributes to the supreme deity not only benevolence, but also powers that make that deity both omniscient and omnipresent (I 4.17–18) when he describes god as “so great and of such a kind as at one and the same time to see everything, to hear everything, to be present everywhere, and to take care of everything.” This theology has a Presocratic history, but not in the tradition of physics. What it unmistakably echoes and develops is the radical theology of Xenophanes,22 who in the late sixth or early fifth century b.c. had satirically denounced the anthropomorphization of gods (21 B 11–16 DK), redescribing the supreme divinity as an unmoved being capable of moving everything by the power of thought alone (B 23–26).
-
1 - So now I understand why the song sounds like the Kinks!

2 - The song is a fun way to dramatize the central question. Radical Skeptics seem likely to say "Sounds good to me!" Let's just say for now that I don't think the way Epicurus spent his life leads to the conclusion that Epicurus - or anyone concerned about the difference between true and false or good and bad - would agree.
QuoteDisplay MoreFull Lyrics:
Something's happenin' but I'm just gonna turn a blind eye
If I see no evil, ask no questions, and I hear no lies
Can't communicate with minds that are small
With some people it's like talkin' to the wall
And a fellow who walks away
Lives to battle another day
And I've really got no appetite
For a fight
Not tonight
All I want is a quiet life
Anything for a quiet life
No ambition to rock the boat
When I can just stay afloat
Be content with a quiet life
All I want is a quiet life
Anything for a quiet life
Hear no evil, see no evil, speak no evil at all
Confidentially, between these walls
I'm on top of it all
I'd rather have 'em think I'm deaf, dumb, and blind
Than aggravation every time I speak my mind
Keep at a quiet life
Anything for a quiet lifeI could easily blow my top
Start a row
But why start now?
Give your daddy a quiet life
Give your mother a quiet life
Anything for a quiet life
Give your daddy a quiet life
Give your mother a quiet life
Anything for a quiet life
Confidentially, between these walls
I'm on top of it all -
One of that paper's conclusions is below. This in my mind takes the wrong position of saying that "Epicureans aimed at pleasure and understood this to consist in ataraxia." So the article has to be read in perspective from one's assessment of the crucial issue of whether they want to equate "ataraxia" and "pleasure" as exactly the same thing to Epicurus - to which there are many pieces of evidence that the answer to that is "no." Pleasure is a wider and more important goal than ataraxia, and even in Epicurean terms Sextus Empiricus sees that - and therefore Sextus does not clearly endorse Epicurus' ethical conclusions as his own.
QuoteLet us return to my original question: can an ancient Greek sceptic be eudaimôn?
The answer, I think, is not entirely straightforward. It is not impossible that a sceptic (not, of course, through any deliberate choice) might happen to live the kind of life that, according to some other school’s account of eudaimonia, would qualify as eudaimôn. This is in fact not going to happen in most cases, given that such specifications of eudaimonia will usually include a component of definite belief that would be anathema to a sceptic. This is clearly true of the Stoic specification, and presumably of the Aristotelian one. But perhaps the sceptic – assuming he did indeed achieve ataraxia – might qualify as eudaimôn as conceived by an Epicurean, albeit via a different route from the one laid down by the Epicureans themselves. For the Epicureans aimed at pleasure, and understood this to consist in ataraxia; and while the Epicureans, unlike the Pyrrhonists, took the route to ataraxia to involve the adoption of certain beliefs about the world, it is not clear that they saw the state of ataraxia as itself incorporating any element of belief. What a sceptic would be advised not to do, if I am right, is himself lay claim to the achievement of eudaimonia, and include it as a component of the sceptical outlook in
a role parallel to the one it occupies in other philosophies; for, as we have seen, the very concept seems to bring with it a number of theoretical presuppositions that one would expect a sceptic to want to avoid. And this, I suspect, is why Sextus decided not to use it in Outlines of Pyrrhonism, even though he had done so in Against the Ethicists -
Apparently a paper very close to Robert's question, with evidence that aiming for happiness is not consistent with suspension of judgment. I haven't read it yet but looks interesting based on the Abstract.
Abstract
The paper explores how far the ancient Greek sceptics in fact accept, and how far they should accept, the central Greek ethical notion of eudaimonia, usually translated "happiness" - and what, if anything, the answers may tell us today. The first section shows that sceptics of both the Academic and Pyrrhonist traditions frequently employ the notion of eudaimonia, apparently without discomfort. The second section draws attention to a contrast within the relevant works of Sextus Empiricus - one of them being willing to speak of the sceptic's eudaimonia and the other entirely avoiding this - and considers some possible reasons why, at some point in his life, Sextus might have found the notion problematic. The answers suggested are, first, that the term eudaimonia, at least as normally used by non-sceptical philosophers, presupposes that it is possible to rank human lives objectively in terms of their levels of well-being, and second, that the term standardly carries with it a commitment to a certain kind of long-term structure in one's life; there is at least a serious question whether either of these is consistent with sceptical suspension of judgement. The third section examines how far a sceptic could aspire to happiness, where this is not assumed to be equivalent to eudaimonia, and touches on several modern philosophers who have focused on happiness or, more generally, on wellbeing. The conclusions are that the notions of happiness and eudaimonia are closer in their presuppositions than one might have expected; that a sceptic would be well advised to avoid either one; and that this constitutes a sobering lesson for anyone today who regards values as in some sense subjective, but who aims to construct a satisfactory conception of happiness.
-
Welcome to Episode 357 of Lucretius Today. This is a podcast dedicated to the poet Lucretius, who wrote "On The Nature of Things," the most complete presentation of Epicurean philosophy left to us from the ancient world. Each week we walk you through the Epicurean texts, and we discuss how Epicurean philosophy can apply to you today. If you find the Epicurean worldview attractive, we invite you to join us in the study of Epicurus at EpicureanFriends.com, where we discuss this and all of our podcast episodes.
This week we are continuing our series reviewing Cicero's "Academic Questions" from an Epicurean perspective, which gives us an overview of the issues that split Plato's Academy and helps us understand Epicurus' position on the same issues. This week will continue in Section 18 of Book 2.
Our text will come from
Cicero - Academic Questions - Yonge We'll likely stick with Yonge primarily, but we'll also refer to the Rackham translation here: Cicero On Nature Of Gods Academica Loeb Rackham : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet ArchiveAs we proceed through the end of Academic Questions, these are the topics we expect to cover:
24. Lucullus's Extended Rebuttal of the Academic Doctrine, and His Concluding Appeal to Cicero (2:XIII)
25. Cicero Begins His Reply (2:XX)
26. Cicero Lays Out the Syllogism About Assent and Opinion (2:XXI)
27. Cicero Turns to Antiochus's Own Inconsistency (2:XXII)
28. Cicero Defends His Citation of the Ancient Philosophers (2:XXIII)
29. Cicero Adds Chrysippus and the Cyrenaics, Then Returns to Arcesilas and Zeno (2:XXIV)
30. Cicero Returns to Attacking the Senses (2:XXV)
31. Cicero Presses the Sun's Size and the Limits of Trained Perception (2:XXVI)
32. Cicero Turns the "Art" Argument Back on Lucullus (2:XXVII)
33. Cicero Multiplies Examples From Madness (2:XXVIII)
34. Cicero Attacks Reason and Dialectics: The Sorites Paradox (2:XXIX)
35. Cicero Presses the Liar Paradox (2:XXX)
36. Cicero Presents Carneades's Own Positive Doctrine of Probability (2:XXXI)
37. Cicero Distinguishes the Academic Position From Epicurus's (2:XXXII)
38. Cicero Defends Probability Against the Charge That It Cannot Support Memory or Action (2:XXXIII)
39. Cicero Answers the "Self-Refuting" and "Two Incompatible Propositions" Objections (2:XXXIV)
40. Cicero Broadens the Argument Beyond the Stoics (2:XXXV)
41. Cicero Reflects on His Own Position Among the Competing Schools (2:XXXVI)
42. Cicero's Survey of Disagreement Among the Natural Philosophers (2:XXXVII)
43. Cicero Presses the Problem of Providence and the Limits of Physics (2:XXXVIII)
44. Cicero's Survey Continues: The Soul, the Antipodes, and the Motion of the Earth (2:XXXIX)
45. Cicero Asks Which Natural Philosopher He Would Even Choose to Follow (2:XL)
46. Cicero Turns to Ethics: Even the Gods Are Disputed (2:XLI)
47. Cicero's Roll Call of Rival Schools on the Chief Good, Part One (2:XLII)
48. Cicero's Roll Call of Rival Schools on the Chief Good, Part Two (2:XLIII)
49. Cicero Weighs Zeno Against Antiochus on Virtue and the Happy Life (2:XLIV)
50. Cicero Catalogs the Stoic Paradoxes About the Wise Man (2:XLV)
51. Cicero's Climactic Debate Between Pleasure and Honor (2:XLVI)
52. Cicero Turns to the Canon of Truth, and Zeno's Hand (2:XLVII)
53. The Dialogue's Close (2:XLVIII)Time for another memorable point:
Sedley alleges that (at least in Greek thought) the first Creationist and first proponent of the Argument from Design was SOCRATES, as documented in Xenophon giving the following argument:
Quote from Sedley, Creationism And Its Critiics In Antiquity, Page 841. Representational artists are admirable creators, even though their products are not living beings.
2. If that which produces living beings does so by mere chance, it is not more admirable than representational artists. (Implicit reason: it manifests less intelligence than they do.)
3. If that which produces living beings does so by design, it is more admirable than representational artists. (Implicit reason: it is an intelligent creative artist, as they are, but a more admirable one, since its products are superior to theirs.)
4. To determine whether that which produces living beings does so by mere chance or by design, we must ask whether its products, living beings, are typical of the products of chance or of those of design.Here we encounter for the first time the explicit disjunction of accident and design, offered as competing causal origins of life. The evidence of systematically purposive structures in nature is then cited by Socrates to discount the first alternative in favor of the second. And his clear, albeit implicit, conclusion is that the origin of life forms lies in a creator superior to any human creator. Do we not have here the earliest instance, or at least direct forerunner, of the Argument from Design?
Let us know in this thread as you come across them and we will address them asap.
One change that our users will note is that the Quote system works a little differently. Once you mark quotes they don't appear at the bottom right of the screen but at the bottom right of any post you are editing, and you can use them as before but from this different location. If anyone finds it confusing just ask about it.
As of about 6:30 PM EDT the forum is back up after the upgrade. No doubt there will be theme and other issues that will need addressing. Let us know in this thread as you come across them and we will address them asap.
As part of the security updates we are going to upgrade the software for the forum over the next several hours. Nothing major should be lost, but the site may be inaccessible during the upgrade. Please don't start any major new posts without having a backup!
Some of you may be aware that over the last several days there have been security issues in software known as "PHP" that runs many internet websites, including this one. I am not aware that this issue has caused us any issues whatsoever so far, but we have today integrated the latest patches so this should not be a problem for us going forward. However security is a constantly moving target so as always, if you detect any weirdness in operation of the forum please contact me so we can address it asap.
Sextus says the goal of the Sceptic is “quietude” (ataraxia), reached by suspending judgement and giving up the search for truth (Outlines I.25–30). He contrasts this directly with the pleasure schools. Pleasure as the end, he says, is “the opposite” of Sceptic quietude (Outlines I.215).


Cassius Thanks for this assessment, but doesn’t Epicurus encourage us to follow our net pleasures to the fullest? If we have been endowed by Nature with capabilities, it would seem UNnatural to not develop those abilities to the fullest extent of net positive pleasure? Instead of “hiding our talents under a bushel” or “living a quiet life in the middle of the nowhere “, I read how Epicurus encourages us to meet and study together with others.
I completely agree with your statement here Patrikios but I cannot come up with a way of quantifying what "greatest pleasure" means across ALL circumstances. I agree very much that for most everyone (probably everyone) they will want to meet and study together with us. But some people in some circumstances are not able to do that for reasons beyond their control - whether it be because they are surrounded by hostile people or hostile environments of many kinds. The advice to seek the greatest pleasure possible under the circumstances would seem to be the way to generalize that, and I think Epicurus is trying to keep the focus on a rule that does apply to everyone in every circumstance.
Clearly for those of us who are the majority of people on the forum now - in a time of relatively free freedom of speech in Western countries - we can and should meet and study together to the extent possible. So yes passive or introverted personalities can be an obstacle to that, but so can societal changes that might be even more outside of someone's control. I certainly am glad that we live where and when we do, but it's probably a good idea to acknowledge that were circumstances to go against us we still be prepared to act to the extent possible.
So that's one part of what you are referring to.
Probably it's also important to say that the circumstances that can go against us can be more subtle - societies get carried away with what we as individuals might deem to be very "bad" ideas about what the greatest happiness / pleasure means. So that's another reason we might find ourselves isolated and fending for ourselves.
But yes I very much agree that it is strongly implicit that we each ACT to the extent possible to secure our pleasure and happiness.
I think DeWitt is right to infer that Epicurus held that even his view of divinity meant that "the gods" must also not just enjoy the benefits of living in the intermundia but also ACT to maintain their own happiness.
I am probably talking about a lot of issues very broadly here but I am essentially agreeing with your premise because I think there's a misconception in some quarters that we can just "relax" and whatever happens to us when we "let go" is the highest pleasure and best we can hope for. I don't think that's what Torquatus means when he references how pleasure takes the place of pain when pain is removed. I very strongly think that is not all that he meant - there are different types and intensities and durations of pleasure, and we have to act if we are going to attain the most pleasant life possible to us. And yes that generally means cultivating like-minded friends and studying and cooperating with them to build happier lives.
Quotet appears that Sedley goes to great lengths to find the creation design theory in many early Ancient Greek philosophers: Anaxagoras, Empedocles, Socrates, Plato & Aristotle. Although the reviewer considers how Sedley twists his writings to fashion Aristotle as supporting creationism, in order to fit in with Sedley’s views on the prior philosophers.
I'm not sure exactly whether this statement by the reviewer is intended as criticism (it appears to be with "twist") but I see no reason to question Sedley's conclusions in what I have read so far. Anytime someone is postulating any kind of "active" force acting on something else which is not active, you're pretty much in creationism territory. I would certainly consider a "prime mover" to be in that same category.
And while it's correct to say that there is no chapter specifically naming Epicurus, the discussion of atomism that I have read so far does a good job of highlighting Epicurus' views and his distinctiveness from Democritus.
Yes if others read the book I would be interested in their comments too. And unfortunately you're right that I'm not aware of a public link with a free copy of the book so finding it will require digging or a library or both.
I expect to have much more to say as I read further, but I am reminded that I am also woefully behind on reading Sextus Empiricus, so I am having to split my time.
I am totally unfamiliar with this name, but it appears he was a major player in the development of Skepticism, and we need to know enough about him to fit him into the big picture:
Like Sextus Empiricus it appears that Aenesidemus wrote in Greek rather than Latin. I wish I were not getting the impression that the most radical forms of skepticism were much more appealing to the Greek mind than to the Roman mind.
This appears to be key:
The ten modes of Aenesidemus
The reasons for doubt are given in the form of the ten "tropes" (also known as ten modes of Aenesidemus or ten tropes of Aenesidemus) that represent reasons for epoché (suspension of judgment). :[5]
- (1) different animals manifest different impressions;
- (2) similar differences are seen among individual people;
- (3) even for the same person, sense-given data are self-contradictory,
- (4) sense data vary from time to time with physical changes, and
- (5) sense-data vary according to local relations;
- (6) and (7) objects are known only indirectly through the medium of air, moisture, &c., and are in a condition of perpetual change in colour, temperature, size and motion;
- (8) all perceptions are relative and interact one upon another;
- (9) Our impressions become less deep by repetition and custom; and
- (10) all people are brought up with different beliefs, under different laws and social conditions.
Aenesidemus argues that truth varies infinitely under circumstances whose relative weight cannot be accurately gauged. There is, therefore, no absolute knowledge, for everyone has different perceptions, and, further, arranges and groups data in methods peculiar to themselves; so that the sum total is a quantity with a purely subjective validity.[5]
I will be adding comments to this thread as I review this book, and the first thing I see to address is this statement from Dr. Sedley about his interest in exploring the history of the debate about creationism. (The underlining is my own addition.)
My interest is in the arguments for and against divine creation and the appeals that were made to its explanatory power. In classical antiquity, these were formulated and deployed by a series of leading philosophers, nearly all of whom agreed, at least tacitly, that settling the issue is fundamental to establishing a proper relationship with the divine, and hence to the quest for human happiness. What is the value of conducting such a historical exercise? For my money, it lies precisely in treating both sides of the ancient debate with equal sympathy. The object is not to determine who was right, but to understand each position’s rationale from the inside. The potential rewards include new historical perspectives on the pantheon of thinkers who laid the foundations of western philosophy and science, perspectives which are likely to enhance our understanding of their ethics, their physics, and even in some cases their logic. But an equally rich recompense lies in the sheer intellectual exercise of thinking one’s way into lines of reasoning with which one may well at the outset have no intuitive sympathy, while establishing a matching critical distance from those one is inclined to favor.
This comment brings up a point we've discussed about how to treat not only Dr. Sedley about also most other academic writers on Epicurus.
Unlike the "series of leading philosophers" who almost all agreed that taking a position on the question of divine creationism is essential to human happiness, Academic Scholars like Dr. Sedley are not intent on answering questions about what leads to happiness. Instead, Dr. Sedley's goal is "not to determine who was right, but to understand each position’s rationale from the inside."
This comment reminds me of what Cicero records in his Academic Questions was the position of the Academic Skeptics in Book 2 Section 18 Yonge.
QuoteThere remains this other statement of theirs, that for the sake of discovering the truth, one ought to speak against every side, and in favour of every side. I wish then to see what they have discovered. We are not in the habit, says he, of showing that. What then is the object of all this mystery? or why do you conceal your opinion as something discreditable? In order, says he, that those who hear us may be influenced by reason rather than led by authority. What if they are influenced by both? would there be any harm in that? However, they do not conceal one of their theories, namely, that there is nothing which can be conceived. Is authority no hindrance to entertaining this opinion? It seems to me to be a great one. For who would ever have embraced so openly and undisguisedly such perverse and false principles, if there had not been such great richness of ideas and power of eloquence in Arcesilas, and, in a still greater degree, in Carneades?
I'm very glad and appreciative that Dr. Sedley wrote his books.
I'm also glad and appreciative that Cicero wrote the books that he did.
But as far as I am concerned my goal is NOT knowledge for the sake of knowledge, nor is it to "understand each's position's rationale from the inside."
It's very very helpful to do exactly what Dr. Sedley and Cicero reference - to understand the important sides of the major arguments. That's the best way to understand the issues. But the purpose of conducting that investigation is for us to decide who was right so we can live the best lives possible. Knowledge for the sake of knowledge is not going to get us to where we want to be.
This following is a more exhaustive list of references prepared by Claude. It addresses simply a request to compile a list of references both positive and negative. Within that scope I think it succeeds pretty well, and provides a set of links for further study, so it's a useful addition to this thread.
Nietzsche on Epicurus, Lucretius, and Epicurean Philosophy
Scope
Nietzsche mentions Epicurus more than 150 times across his published works, philological writings, notebooks, and correspondence. The table below covers:
- All substantial direct references in Nietzsche's published philosophical works.
- The principal references to Lucretius.
- Major implicit engagements with Epicurean doctrines recognized in the scholarship.
- The most important letters and posthumous notebook entries.
It excludes passing uses of "epicurean" that merely mean luxurious or pleasure-loving, minor philological details, and repetitive preparatory notes that add no distinct philosophical content.
Tone key: ++ strongly affirmative · + favorable · ± mixed/ambivalent · − critical
Published works
Date Work and citation Subject Tone Significance 1886 The Birth of Tragedy, "Attempt at a Self-Criticism" §1 Epicureanism − Nietzsche asks whether the Epicurean opposition to pessimism is merely the self-protection of a sufferer. This inaugurates his later physiological critique: Epicurean serenity may express vulnerability to pain rather than strength. Primary text 1878 Human, All Too Human I §68 Epicurus and science ++ Nietzsche says that emerging science has allied itself "point by point" with Epicurus while rejecting Christianity point by point. Epicurean naturalism is presented as historically vindicated. Primary text 1878 Human, All Too Human I §275 Epicureans and Cynics ± Nietzsche says the Epicurean and Cynic share a basic standpoint but differ temperamentally. The Cynic displays independence aggressively; the Epicurean withdraws more quietly and discreetly. Passage 1879 Human, All Too Human II, Assorted Opinions and Maxims §408, "The Journey to Hades" Epicurus as interlocutor ++ Epicurus and Montaigne head Nietzsche's list of eight dead thinkers with whom he must continually "come to terms." Nietzsche seeks their approval and correction and calls them more genuinely alive than many living people. 1880 The Wanderer and His Shadow §7, "Two Means of Consolation" Epicurean therapy ++ Epicurus is the "soul-soother of later antiquity." Nietzsche praises his insight that peace of mind does not require final answers to ultimate metaphysical questions. Epicurus's method is offered as a therapy for the distressed and dying. German primary text 1880 The Wanderer and His Shadow §192, "The Philosophy of Luxury" Simple pleasure ++ Epicurus's garden, figs, cheese, and a few friends exemplify authentic luxury: sufficiency, friendship, and cultivated simplicity rather than opulence. Primary text 1880 The Wanderer and His Shadow §227, "Eternal Epicurus" Epicurus's continuing existence ++ Nietzsche says Epicurus has always remained alive, including in people unaware that they are Epicureans. Epicurus's greatest liberation was throwing off even the burden of his own name and reputation. Discussion and citation 1880 The Wanderer and His Shadow §295, "Et in Arcadia ego" Heroic-idyllic philosophy ++ Nietzsche calls Epicurus "one of the greatest men" and the inventor of a "heroic-idyllic" manner of philosophizing: serenely inhabiting the present world without yearning for another. Primary text 1880 The Wanderer and His Shadow §332 Epicurean imagery + Although Epicurus is not named, the sunlight, stillness, nearby things, and self-contained happiness extend the "heroic-idyllic" imagery of §295. Scholarship regularly reads §§295 and 332 together as Epicurean. 1881 Daybreak §72, "The 'After Death'" Epicurus and Lucretius against fear ++ Epicurus's attempt to uproot belief in posthumous punishment is called an immense benefit. Lucretius is the enlightened disciple in whose poetry Epicurus's victory sounds most beautifully. Christianity temporarily defeated that liberation, but modern science allows "Epicurus [to] triumph anew." Passage 1881 Daybreak §150, "The Accident of Marriage" Epicurean gods ± Nietzsche compares withdrawal from the frustrating spectacle of human marriage and reproduction to the gods of Epicurus retreating into divine serenity. The reference is humorous but sympathetic to Epicurean detachment. German critical text 1881 Daybreak §§13, 33, 36 Freedom from fear + These passages do not name Epicurus, but develop a recognizably Epicurean therapy of fear, chance, guilt, and supernatural interpretation. They are commonly treated as part of Nietzsche's Epicurean program in Daybreak. Scholarly analysis 1881 Daybreak §174 The enclosed garden with a hospitable gate + Nietzsche contrasts coercively transforming others with creating a beautiful, restful, self-contained garden that others may freely enter. Scholars identify this as a distinctly Epicurean model of friendship and ethical influence. 1881 Daybreak §211 Mortality and immortality + Nietzsche ridicules the desire for personal immortality. This continues the Epicurean attack on fear of death developed explicitly in §72. 1881 Daybreak §425 Fidelity to the earth + Nietzsche criticizes people who regard earthly life as a temporary visit because they imagine themselves too important for mortality. The argument extends Epicurean mortalism and opposition to an afterlife. 1881 Daybreak §501 Mortal souls + Nietzsche directs his teaching toward finite, mortal beings rather than immortal souls. Scholars identify this as a culmination of Daybreak's Epicurean therapeutic project. 1882 The Gay Science §45, "Epicurus" Epicurus's character ++ Nietzsche says he is proud to understand Epicurus differently from almost everyone else. He pictures Epicurus serenely looking over the sunlit sea and experiencing the "afternoon happiness" of antiquity. This is his most affectionate portrait of Epicurus. Passage 1882 The Gay Science §277, "Personal Providence" Epicurean providence without gods + Epicurus is not named, but Nietzsche describes a naturalistic feeling of personal providence arising from the fortunate interpretation of events—not divine supervision. Editors commonly connect this passage with Epicurean theology and cite it alongside §§45 and 306. 1882 The Gay Science §306, "Stoic and Epicurean" Competing disciplines of life +/± The sensitive Epicurean carefully chooses situations, companions, and experiences; the Stoic trains himself to endure whatever happens. Nietzsche recommends Epicurean arrangements for intellectual workers who expect to "spin a long thread," while acknowledging Stoicism's usefulness in violent and unstable conditions. Primary text 1887 The Gay Science §370, "What Is Romanticism?" Epicurus as a sufferer −/± Nietzsche now interprets Epicurus physiologically as the opposite of a Dionysian pessimist: someone whose need for serenity, bounded horizons, and release from suffering produced his philosophy. Epicurus remains psychologically profound but no longer represents Nietzsche's highest ideal. Primary text 1887 The Gay Science §375, "Why We Seem to Be Epicureans" Epicurean knowledge + Nietzsche identifies modern free spirits with an "almost Epicurean" desire for knowledge: cautious about ultimate convictions, resistant to moral grandiosity, conscious of ambiguity, and practiced in intellectual reserve. Primary text 1883 Thus Spoke Zarathustra II, "On the Blessed Isles" and its setting The Garden and Blessed Isles +/± Epicurus is not named, but Nietzsche later disclosed that the Blessed Isles were conceived in relation to Epicurus's Garden and the island of Ischia. Much of Part II occurs in this garden-like community of friends. Zarathustra nevertheless begins moving beyond secluded Epicurean self-cultivation toward more expansive transformation. Scholarly reconstruction 1886 Beyond Good and Evil §62 A manner "no longer Epicurean" −/± Nietzsche contrasts the Epicurean temperament with the hammer-bearing critic enraged by Christianity's deformation of European humanity. "Epicurean" here means restrained, non-interventionist, and insufficiently severe for Nietzsche's new project. Passage 1886 Beyond Good and Evil §200 Epicurean happiness as repose − Epicureanism and Christianity are grouped as tranquilizing medicines for internally divided, exhausted people. Their happiness is rest, freedom from disturbance, satiety, and final reconciliation—contrasted with stronger types stimulated by internal conflict. Passage 1886 Beyond Good and Evil §270 Epicureanism as disguise ± Nietzsche calls Epicureanism one of the most refined masks for profound suffering. A person may display cheerfulness and take suffering lightly precisely to prevent others from recognizing how deeply he has suffered. Passage 1887 On the Genealogy of Morality III §6 Epicurus's painless state ± Nietzsche quotes Schopenhauer identifying aesthetic contemplation with the painless state praised by Epicurus as the highest good. Nietzsche then diagnoses the ideal as the temporary relief of a sufferer escaping the "torture" of willing. Primary text 1887 On the Genealogy of Morality III §17 Epicurean anesthesia −/± Nietzsche compares religious redemption and mystical sleep with the philosophy of the "clear, cold, Greekly cold, but suffering Epicurus." Epicurean ataraxia is interpreted as anesthesia sought by someone exhausted by suffering. Primary text 1888 Nietzsche contra Wagner, "We Antipodes" Epicurus versus Dionysus −/± Nietzsche repeats and slightly adapts Gay Science §370: Epicurus is the opposite of a Dionysian Greek, and Christianity is interpreted as a radicalized Epicurean hedonism. This is a republication, not an independent new argument. Primary text 1888 The Antichrist §30 Epicureanism as pagan salvation −/± Nietzsche calls Epicureanism the pagan doctrine of salvation most closely related to Jesus's practice, although endowed with much more Greek vitality. He also calls Epicurus a "typical décadent," interpreting fear of pain as the physiological source of the doctrine. Primary passage 1888 The Antichrist §58 Epicurus and Lucretius against Christianity ++ Nietzsche presents Epicurus as the ancient combatant against guilt, punishment, immortality, and the subterranean cults that anticipated Christianity. He directs the reader to Lucretius to understand this struggle, says denial of immortality was liberation, and declares that Epicurus would have prevailed had Paul not intervened. Primary passage Philological writings, notebooks, and correspondence
Date Source and citation Subject Tone Significance 1867 De Laertii Diogenis fontibus, KGW II/1, pp. 75–167, especially p. 89 Sources for Diogenes Laertius on Epicurus + In this prize-winning philological study, Nietzsche argues that Diocles of Magnesia supplied much of Diogenes Laertius's account of Epicurus. Nietzsche describes Diocles's spirit as preferring rest in Epicurus's gardens to the icy Stoic Porch. Discussion and citation 1867–68 Early philological notebooks, HKGW IV, especially pp. 42, 54, 65, 74–78, 120, 364, 501 Lucretius, atomism, and recurrence ± Nietzsche made numerous notes on Lucretius while researching Democritus and ancient atomism. Of special importance is Lucretius's argument that, given infinite time and material combinations, configurations of matter recur—an early source relevant to Nietzsche's later interest in recurrence. Scholarly source 16 Aug. 1883 Letter to Heinrich Köselitz/Peter Gast, KSB 6:452 The atmosphere of Epicurus's Garden ++ Nietzsche praises Gast's letters for conveying the "air and fragrance" of Epicurus's Garden and the divine art of eluding the crowd. He connects this atmosphere with Zarathustra's Blessed Isles and Ischia. Aug. 1883 Letter to Köselitz/Gast, KSB 6:457 Epicurus's disciples ++ Nietzsche says he envies Epicurus his disciples in the Garden. The remark illuminates Nietzsche's own desire for a small community of serious philosophical pupils. 1884 Notebook 25[95], KSA 11; later printed misleadingly as The Will to Power §1029 Epicurean delight versus Dionysian joy − Nietzsche says his knowledge confronts such terrible possibilities that "Epicurean delight" is no longer adequate; only Dionysian joy can affirm them. This sharply formulates his movement beyond Epicurean tranquility. Citation and discussion Spring 1888 Notebook 14[99], KSA 13.276–77 Epicurus and Pyrrho − Nietzsche calls Pyrrho and Epicurus two forms of Greek decadence, united by hostility to dialectics and theatrical virtue and by representing an indeterminate condition between sickness and health, life and death. Scholarly transcription Spring 1888 Notebook 15[5], KSA 13.403 Philosophy as decadence − Epicurus appears within Nietzsche's late attempt to interpret certain philosophies of tranquility as expressions of exhaustion or "wise fatigue." 1888 Notebook 16[15] Epicurus's reputation and strength ± Nietzsche observes that later caricatures reduced Epicureans to "swine," while Seneca nevertheless testifies to Epicurus's masculinity and spiritual distinction. The entry preserves Nietzsche's respect for Epicurus even during his late critique of Epicurean decadence. Condensed citation list
For a compact bibliography or footnote, the central references are:
QuoteNietzsche, The Birth of Tragedy, "Attempt at a Self-Criticism" §1; Human, All Too Human I §§68, 275; Assorted Opinions and Maxims §408; The Wanderer and His Shadow §§7, 192, 227, 295; Daybreak §§72, 150; The Gay Science §§45, 306, 370, 375; Beyond Good and Evil §§62, 200, 270; On the Genealogy of Morality III §§6, 17; Nietzsche contra Wagner, "We Antipodes"; and The Antichrist §§30, 58.
Interpretive trajectory
Period General position Early philological period Epicurus and Lucretius matter principally as ancient materialists, naturalists, and historical-philological subjects. Middle/free-spirit period, 1878–82 Nietzsche's most affirmative phase: Epicurus is a liberator from superstition, master of modest pleasure, philosophical therapist, model of friendship, and inventor of heroic-idyllic philosophizing. Transitional period, 1883–85 Nietzsche retains the imagery of the Garden and philosophical friendship but increasingly contrasts secluded tranquility with a more demanding Dionysian affirmation. Late period, 1886–88 Epicurus becomes ambivalent: still intellectually noble and an ally against Christianity, but physiologically interpreted as a sufferer whose doctrine seeks repose, anesthesia, and protection from pain. The Antichrist §58 The late critique does not erase Nietzsche's admiration: Epicurus and Lucretius remain exemplary enemies of guilt, punishment, immortality, and proto-Christian religious terror. This chronology is important: Nietzsche never simply changes from "pro-Epicurus" to "anti-Epicurus." He continues to admire Epicurus's character, naturalism, intellectual honesty, and opposition to religious fear even while rejecting ataraxia as the highest form of life. Modern scholarship accordingly describes Epicurus as a persistent Nietzschean "touchstone," not merely a youthful influence. Overview
I just heard from Eikadistes that he's been working on the Oxyrhunchus materials. Haven't had a chance to review it yet but his work is always of high quality so we definitely want to link to it here:
ΟΙ ΠΑΠΥΡΟΙ ΤΗΣ ΟΞΥΡΡΥΓΧΟΥ – TwentiersThis webpage contains the remaining fragments of Epicurean epistles found in the papyri that were discovered in Oxyrhynchus, Egypt in 1894.twentiers.com